Having collected CWT's and particularly those from NY for the past sixty years, to my experience, these clashed die Broas pie tokens are fairly common. There are currently a half dozen or so over-priced specimens, languishing on
ebay. Token dealers at shows often have these in stock at much lower prices, too. This major striking error, although common to this merchant's tokens, doesn't typically command BIG BUCKS. This particular merchant issued many thousands of tokens.
IMHO. the OP's token might well slab MS-63 and then be worth $150-$200, my guesstimate. There are a great many errors to be had in the CWT series, and this issue, common as it is, is perhaps the strongest of the clashed die errors. Great pick-up at the price paid!