"Rare" Mutilated PMD Coins Are Only Worth Scap Value!

Coin 2 has been deliberately defaced with a Dremel or similar tool.

Coins 1 and 3 look very typical of the kinds of coins that fall out of scrapped cars as they're being pulled apart.

I think these coins might just qualify as "damaged", rather than "mutilated" - they don't seem to have large pieces missing and may not be underweight. But you'd really have to ask at your bank. If you took these three coins to the bank, it's most likely the bank would accept them for face, then toss them in the weekly bulk scrap bag for returning to the Mint. It's not worth the negative PR to ask a customer to fill in forms etc for just a few coins. If you tried to bank a thousand of the things, that's a different question.

I seem to recall some years ago, the Mint was hit by a scam where the scrap metal dealers that the Mint itself was sending scrap coins off to, was returning the scrapped coins to the banks. Hence the provision that coins "damaged in any industrial process (including scrap metal processing)" are no longer redeemable.

Evil has an eternity of faces.