Should I Scrap These Silver Eagles?

Thanks thats what I thought too, kinda looks ugly to me so rather have the extra $40 lol

That specific toning will not get better. It's always going to be dark, regardless of what happens to the rest of the surface.

If it was me, I wouldn't scrap them.

I'd like to reply a little more generally to what you're doing with scrapping the silver.
If you intend on taking it to a coin shop or "WE BUY SILVER" shop, I'd really think a little or at least hear me out.
These places don't really offer the best return on the coins. , for the most part, are not even going to give you the melt value. They offer a pretty good percentage below even that. Understandable, they need to stay in business.
Your best bet is online sales to other stackers. I believe even ebay sales will pay better, even with the fees.
My recommendation is joining a few Facebook pages dealing with silver and gold sales. I belong to a few and have done pretty good dealing with stackers directly. I usually do a24 hour style auction, where the bidding is ended 24 hours after the last bid. If you're not on Facebook, I guess this isn't a good option. I wouldn't do Facebook marketplace, that's not what I'm suggesting. Just look your options over before you sell to a local shop.

I agree. Do not scrap them! Selling to a stacker would be my choice.

They are just bullion, so as mentioned above, a quick dip (acid & thiourea, e.g. e-Z-est, Jewel Luster, etc.) with remove the spots and improve their "curb appeal" on the Bay. Remember to rinse well after dipping.

Even if you do not want to mess with the dip, you might still find a buyer at a better rate than a recycler.

@Gilly Thank you very much I will go look at some fb pages tonight and see about selling my silver there instead. I have 40+ pieces left AU55+ (from what iv been told, I wouldnt know grades yet) so ill try Fb and see where that goes. I appreciate the information a lot, thank you.

My opinion is it's not going to increase what a stacker is going to pay. If anything it makes the coins seem more authentic if they have the natural toning on them. The Chinese don't try replicating toning. I'd leave them alone, the juice isn't worth the squeeze.