Thanks to all for the discussion on this coin. I learn what other collectors think and value. This particular variety is a 5 star coin per Rick Snow. According to Snow the "strong" version is the only one to collect. The so-called "weak" version has no premium above the normal 1858 mintage coin. I have been looking for this variety of coin for many years. When I cherry-pick one I am always excited. I potentially have found another one and it is currently in shipment. If it turns out to be the overdate, I will post it.



















