| Author |
Replies: 131 / Views: 4,892 |
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
1291 Posts |
In celebration of my soon-to-be 250th post, I'm having a bidding contest (I know that SOUNDS like an auction, but read on) where 100% of the proceeds will all go to the nice folks who run this forum. Here's how this works: There are two groups of coins pictured below. You can only bid on one of them. You have to specify in your bid if you want coin group 1 or coin group 2. There is no minimum bid. You can bid one cent and try to "steal" one of the groupings, if you'd like. The CATCH to all this is, you can only win if someone else bids the exact same amount on the other group that you did NOT choose, and only if that person names you as their partner. The two highest, matching bids will win. (There's a theoretical example of how this works, below. Please read on...) So why is this a CONTEST, and not an auction? It's because I expect a contest of strategies. There may be some who want to partner with someone else to win the groups at a low price. There may be others who want to help benefit The Forum without actually winning and having to pay for the coins, so their strategy might be to bid up the low-ballers. Still others may want to see The Forum make some decent bucks off of this, but if they bid too high, perhaps no one else will care to match that high bid. And here is an important rule: You can bid multiple times, but only under these conditions: If there is a set of matching bids that is greater than your un-matched bid, you may bid again OR you may match someone else who has already bid higher than the current high matching bids.
If there is a set of matching bids that is higher than you and your partner's matching bids, you may bid again OR you may match someone who has already bid higher than the current high matching bids.
If your unmatched bid is higher than the current highest matching set of bids, you CANNOT bid again. You must wait for your bid to be exceeded by two matching bids before you can bid again OR you can "campaign" to try to find a partner to match your bid.
If you have already bid, and there are no matching bids whatsoever, you cannot bid. You must wait for two others to match and then see where your bid is in relation to that match.
If you have already bid, and there are no matches whatsoever, you are NOT ALLOWED to match someone else's bid. You must wait until there is a match and then see where your bid is in relation to that match.You are NOT required to keep the same partner throughout the contest, but if you have an unmatched bid you cannot "decline" someone who wants to partner with you.Here is a theoretical way this might play out. Let's pretend there are only 5 members on this forum who participate. We'll call them M1, M2, M3 M4 and M5. M3 starts the bidding by bidding 1.00 on group 2 M2 bids $5.00 on group 1 M4 bids $5.00 on group 2 and adds, "I match M2" (At this point, there is no longer any sense in bidding $5.00 or less. M2 and M4 have locked up the $5.00 level. But the game goes on...) M1 bids $40.00 on group 2. (Wow! Big spender!) M3 (his earlier bid has been eclipsed by the M2 M4 $5.00 match) now bids $6.00 on group 2 M5 bids $6.00 on Group 1 and says, "I match M3"M4 bids $10.00 on group 2 M2 bids $10.00 on group 1 and says "I match M4" M1 adds to the levity by writing, "You people are a bunch of cheap-skates!" M3 bids $10.00 on group 2 and says "I match M2" At this point I step in and say to M3 "No you don't! M2 and M4 are already partnered at the $10.00 level. You have no partner! M3 curses under his breath and bids $10.01 on group 2... M5 decides he really doesn't want to spend this much and does NOT match or bid Time goes by. The contest reaches it's deadline. BZZZZTTT! The final buzzer goes off! M2 and M4 are declared the winners at $10.00 each. I mail them their respective groups of coins and The Forum becomes $20.00 richer as I send them $20.00 via PayPal. M3 wonders why M5 bailed on him and why nobody else likes him. M1 comments again, "You people are a bunch of cheapies!" Contest ends at midnight eastern time on June 13th.Questions? Here are the coins:     Edited by weerdsteev 05/31/2009 2:23 pm
|
|
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
1231 Posts |
$5 on lot 1
Edited by onejinx 05/31/2009 1:02 pm
|
|
Pillar of the Community
 United States
5953 Posts |
"I match onejinx"
$5 on lot 2
Edited by nohope587 05/31/2009 4:37 pm
|
|
Pillar of the Community
 United States
1291 Posts |
Nohope587: Are you matching onejinx? If so, say "I match onejinx", otherwise, yours is just a random bid that can be matched by someone else.
|
|
Valued Member
United States
100 Posts |
8$ on lot 1
thanks for this confusing but interesting contest
|
|
Bedrock of the Community
United States
10284 Posts |
$8.00 on Lot 2 and I match StarmanThank you for the generous lots and then also for donating the amount of winning bids. OK Starman, I think we are partners,  if I miss something PM me, as I will do the same for you.
Edited by TNG 05/31/2009 8:58 pm
|
|
Pillar of the Community
 United States
1291 Posts |
Starman: Confusing...? Why, this is so easy a caveman could do it! 
|
|
Pillar of the Community
 United States
1291 Posts |
Here is where we are RIGHT NOW: (June 1, 9:25 AM EST)
Starman and wheezydog have the lead at $8.00 each.
Those two $8.00 bids beat out the $5.00 bids that were received earlier from onejinx and nohope587.
At this point, there is no sense in bidding less than $8.01. Onejinx and nohope587 are eligible to bid again. They can remain partners or split up if one does not wish to match the other.
If this contest ended right now, The Forum would only get $16.00. Starman and wheezydog would make out like bandits!
Edited by weerdsteev 06/01/2009 09:24 am
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
3077 Posts |
|
|
Bedrock of the Community
United States
10284 Posts |
Just to show you I think I understand .... I like Yotie I could bail on Starman and bid on Group 2 at $8.50 and hook up with Yotie, but I am faithful to my partner and hope to see Starman bid $9.00 as well on the other lot soon. I bid $9.00 on lot 2Am I doing this right? Starman can bail on me and go with Yotie or he can join me and say I match wheezydog and bid $9.00 on lot 1 .... right? 
Edited by TNG 06/01/2009 10:37 am
|
|
Pillar of the Community
 United States
1291 Posts |
wheezy - You are smarter than the average caveman! You've got it! Right on! If I fall off the earth, I know I can trust YOU to run this contest!
Edited by weerdsteev 06/01/2009 10:43 am
|
|
Valued Member
United States
100 Posts |
yes I will stick with wheezy and bid 9 
|
|
Valued Member
United States
100 Posts |
Hmmm... I am still confused  This contest doesn't cost the players money does it? cause I dont have pay pal and that kind of stuff.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
 United States
1291 Posts |
Yes, we're playing with real money and at the end I will be sending you real coins...the ones shown in the photos. PayPal is not necessary, but a checkbook would be helpful...
I am basically "donating" these coins so that the Forum can benefit by the proceeds. If you win, I send you the coins, you send me your money and I turn around and donate it (your money) to the Forum.
Edited by weerdsteev 06/01/2009 10:57 am
|
|
Valued Member
United States
326 Posts |
I would like to bid $11 on Lot 2.
|
|
Bedrock of the Community
United States
10284 Posts |
Thanks Starman for hanging tough, if money is a problem, it's OK if you have to bail, but the way it stands at this moment if it ended. I would send 9 bucks to weerdsteev and so would you. He would mail me the Lot pictured in No 2 and you would send him a check for 9 bucks and get the coins pictured in lot 1. weerdsteev would send our money to CCF as a donation. He has in a sense donated these coins to CCF ( The long weerd way around ) We get them, we pay for them. Notice that the lots look similar but are two sets of similar coinage. The only thing Starman you might want to do is edit your post to say I bid $9.00 for Lot 1 and I match wheezydog or You can even say I bid $8.50 on Lot 2 and I match Yotie and then I am without a partner. Then You and Yotie would only have to pay $8.50 each if it were over now.
Me go make fire now. Ogg
|
| |
Replies: 131 / Views: 4,892 |