nickelsearcher,
It's a double-edged sword. If your coin is lost on it's way to PCGS insurance will cover your stated value. If you declare the higher value for insurance and submit for grading at the lower value, you may have some issues. PCGS will insure it at its graded value on the return. I think you are within reason to submit this for economy grading.
I sent a Morgan in last year that I thought was a lock for MS65. It was a common date and eligible for economy grading. It came back MS66 (now an $800 coin) and I paid no addional fees.
It's a double-edged sword. If your coin is lost on it's way to PCGS insurance will cover your stated value. If you declare the higher value for insurance and submit for grading at the lower value, you may have some issues. PCGS will insure it at its graded value on the return. I think you are within reason to submit this for economy grading.
I sent a Morgan in last year that I thought was a lock for MS65. It was a common date and eligible for economy grading. It came back MS66 (now an $800 coin) and I paid no addional fees.



















