I don't know if I would return something that was gifted to me unless it was something you wear and it didn't fit. I guess I am just that way though, I have things fellow collectors have given me that I do not even collect myself but I will not get rid of those things no matter what. I would sell some of the coins I had purchased that I do collect before I would get rid of the gifts. I had someone do something like this to me once and it made me feel like it wasn't good enough for them, it was free to them so what why does it matter what it looks like, if they cared as much about me as I did for them they would want the original gift instead of one they picked out they liked better. If you return something someone bought you the sentimental value goes with it in my opinion. All of this is just the way I feel and I am sure others have different opinions but if I didn't pay I don't feel as if I have the right to be picky, I am just happy someone cared and thought enough about me to give me the gift in the first place