Quote:
The 1922 and 22-D both have a notoriously weak strike, leading to those Lincolns being more leniently graded and having a higher grade that what it looks like at first.
Actually, the strike has nothing to do with it imo. The obverse die itself for the 22 plain is heavily deteriorated to the point that even a powerhouse strike wouldn't show much detail.
Quote:
I really thought this coin was G-4/6 but would not be graded because of the cuts.
Well it did receive a "details" grade from ANACS because of the cuts. If it had been sent to PCGS, it probably would have ended up in a genuine slab. I knew it was a problem coin, and the price I asked reflected that. It would have been a fair price for a G-4 details, but I would think a VG-8 details would go for around $500 or so; and that is probably what I would have asked if I had it graded before selling.

Thank you for your responses, and you are correct that the buyer got it for a great deal. Since I paid $100 for it, I made a nice profit, and since it graded at VG, it leaves plenty of meat on the numismatic bone if he decides to resell it.

I'm glad that in the end I didn't get accused of undergrading...since he thought it was AG, and I was saying G-4/6.