1755 Pillar Copy

odentheviking Looks like a nice earlier Numismatic copy. These were often made from transfer impressions. Depending upon the method used - the image can transfer VERY UNEVENLY. Normally the area near the perimeter of the die - where the lettering is - comes out weak and it is re-engraved out of necessity. I believe that is what accounts for the poor lettering that you point out. If they had actually engraved the "artwork" it would be just as BAD.

A weak initial impression made by transfer often needs some touch up work. Always look for evidence of that type of action being taken. But be aware that you need to be able to identify a repaired die and tell the difference.

Also be aware that the newer silver copies are MUCH better looking than this one and they ring correctly. They usually sell for $15 over bullion. I am working on a date set for Mexico City of that specific type.

By the looks of its edge alone signifies it's counterfeit. Fake Pillar Dollars are really almost everywhere nowadays.
Sad part is, it is continously developing stronger eye appeal that sometimes, it is almost in perfect state as the genuine ones.

I'm glad that most of the modern cap & ray counterfeits are still crude and can be spotted a mile away but getting into the pillars is going to take some researching.