Look At This Toned Morgan

That or dipping!

Oh, big time. I was being more sarcastic. I've heard of people removing beautiful toning such as this, because they favor a "white" coin. How wrong their decision was :'(

Oh My, that is a beautiful coin.
I believe it is on consignment by a member from across the street, and I have held this coin in hand (it was then in an NGC 65* Pl holder). It is a monster, and the colors just explode when looking at it from any angle in hand due to the pl surfaces.
I have both bought and sold with this seller, so I am very familiar with what is represented by him and what the coins look like in hand. He does tweek his pics with photoshop to try to represent the colors as they appear at their best in hand. On toners, the look changes with every tilt of the coin, and some coins only come to life at certain angles, and that's tough to tell from a single image. FWIW, he takes several images of consignment coins and lets the consigner pick the ones he uses.
As for price, I could see 5k for that coin in a ms66 or ms67 holder, but not in ms65.

That statement completely ignores the market for toned coins. Monster toners can and do sell for a 5-20x premium over normal value. I personally have never paid that kind of premium(I like to buy my toners cheap and flip them for a profit) but I would certainly pay a hefty ransom for a stunningly toned coin that has a place in my personal collection.

Ya the color is just too bold and or artificial for me. I understand premium-almost bought a ASE for $300- but $4500 is robbery for that coin.

If I were to buy a toner on ebay, it would be from either john-strategies, eternitycoin, mbcoins, or kryptonitecomics. they seem to be the best at accurately describing color with little or no photoshopping.

I believe beautifully toned coins demand a premium. At the Long Beach show here in So. Cal., there is one dealer that has slabbed morgans that look amazing, every color of the spectrum can be seen on his coins. Every year, the same coins are sitting in his case because of what he wants for them. For that kind of money, I'd rather have a higher grade piece of early Draped Bust copper.
I use to have a "rainbow" CC Morgan and would like to have another some day. Mine was a GSA and wish I still had it :-(