Quote:
Rob, I'm still thinking it's real, but, counterfeiters are really, really good these days and at times you need high power microscopes to detect problem coins. This may be the case in this instance.
I Believe it is real too. Leave it to me to go for a coin like this. LOL.
Quote:
SEND IT IN
OKAY!
Quote:
I noticed the die clash in the perfect spot to the right of the eagles left wing and have never seen a counterfeit with that.
Is that die clash specific to one of the VAMs/dies?
Quote:
89cc for $450 a few towns over from me but that one definitely looked "off" (china 9 I believe)
What's china 9?
Quote:
Sorry to get off subject, just wanted to let you know you sparked a stronger interest in this subject for me
I'm glad I could help.
Quote:
I will just add that it has that correct look with the frost so much associated with Comstock silver ;) I wish you luck! Let us know.
I know, right? It's frosty like the 3 slabbed CC's I have. It looks SO REAL.
Quote:
I probably should have explained myself earlier but I mentioned the crack by the E in America partly because I haven't found any mention of a die crack at that location on genuine examples yet. Though I can't be entirely sure from the first pics, it seems to have a mushy appearance which I remember learning can happen to fine details like die cracks during the transfer die process.
Is a die crack something that doesn't usually appear of counterfeits? It doesn't seem mushy on my end. I can see it without the loupe.
Quote:
Here I've cobbled together this coin against reverses A-E from the Anacs article.
Thanks for posting that up.
Quote:
I believe at this point the OP is planning on getting it certified which will answer any and all questions. My fingers and toes crossed for you, rob oz!
Thank you.
Quote:
Not sure about the rules about posting links to other forums, but this coin is being discussed over there as well.
Indeed. I was curious to see if anyone else had any other info that may not have been stated here that could shed some light.
Quote:
You might not want to read that thread...a few of those guys weren't exactly modest or polite
It was a waste of time for the most part. Just downright rude.
Quote:
To CCF's credit--people were welcoming and helpful here
Credit and then some. I've been around on many forums... Cars, computers, graphic design.... CCF was my first coin forum... I can honestly say that this is the first forum where I was glad to have come to. The discussion was on track. Peoples replied in a matter that actually tried to shed some light. though the biggest thing, I really feel like people are truly genuine in what they say here at CCF. I;m not saying that just to say it, I was actually thinking it last night.
Quote:
I left that site because I was targeted by at least one moderator and was fed up with their attitudes. There are a few decent individuals there, but on the whole this place is much better.
I could see that. We only got like 1 or 2 pages in before it all went haywire. Where on page 7 here at CCF and all 7 pages are informational and helpful... Not filled with nonsense.
Quote:
On a different topic, when are you planning sending it in rob oz?
Hopefully soon. I called PCGS earlier on my lunch break just to see what the prices were and get familiar with the whole process to sending it out. There is a PCGS dealer in my area and I'd like to talk with him to see what he thinks and or has to say about the coin. Though he's by appointment only I believe.
Quote:
I remember reading a thread here a while ago and I thought to myself I would not purchase that particular coin. SsuperDdave aptly pointed out, "No guts, no glory". The bottom line is if you feel the risk is within reason and you have backed it up with some sort of support (in your case here a dealer friend), then bully to you for taking a chance.
I've always been somewhat of a rebel but not necessarily a high risk taker. I tossed around the Idea of what if's in my head. What if it's real? What if it's fake. I just said, what the hey.... Just go for it and see what happens. So here I am. LOL.
Quote:
rob oz, I wish you all the best with this coin. Please keep us posted.
Thanks and I will. Not gonna leave you guys hanging.