"Almost Mint" Really? 1921 Morgan Dollar.

But you didn't answer the question. Why would you think you would get a refund without returning it?


That's not how it works. You return the item - any item - to get a refund. Otherwise it's theft.

The only major distraction on this coin is the big scratch to the left of U in Unum. two pinhole marks on chin, two pinhole marks below ear. if you don't like what he sent you, all you had to do was to return it within 14 days for a full refund. buying $25 dollar Morgans on e-bay without seeing photos of the coin your biding on is not the best way to obtain them. Don't want to make you feel bad but if you wanted a refund ; don't say you are keeping the coin anyway.

Over-reacting for sure. I agree with AU-55 as a grade, pretty much "almost mint" in my book. The scratch really isn't big enough to qualify as damage to a grading service (not that this common coin would be worth having graded). Doesn't look harshly cleaned either, although the diagonal striations between the wreath and the eagle's left (facing) wing might be hairlines from an abrasive rub in that area.

Looks like a perfectly good coin for a "silver stacker" who is putting away bullion-related silver coins!

It bears mentioning - only in passing because ebay doesn't enforce their rules any more - that "stock" coin images aren't allowed, and therefore neither is this type of coin auction.

Rule #5 - Only buy from sellers who offer a refund.

Silver Stacker if you feel that the seller's description was not accurate then you should return the coin for a refund. This seller could have included that some coins may be scratched or cleaned.

I have the coin grade at AU Details and you paid fair market value.

just to clear things up I guess I just wanted the seller to know the coin was cleaned and had a scratch on it rather than actually returning it because I want to keep it for silver.


I am using it as that now rather than replacing the one in my 7070.




In the light the vertical striations on the obverse and reverse are a lot more obvious. + the coin does not have any cartwheel.

And the only reason I was angry because the title says gorgeous, and she is just pretty.

All great advice for newcomers to ebay. I personally putt no returns which I know hurts my sales but I always offer a return once I receive payment and see who I'm dealing with. I've seen to many problems with coins being switched and rather take longer to find a buyer and then offer 100 % satisfaction. I've managed to keep 100% feedback and not been burned yet.

I use flat clinch staples and staple the flip over a piece of white sticker.
If I see any tampering by trying to remove the coin from its original holder, the return is void.
I state this clearly in my terms. Have not had one sent back yet.