So far I just want all the listed varieties, but I've been just buying any 1859 at a reasonable price I can find since I've been enjoying using the haxby website to identify dies. It's like a little riddle to solve.
I found a Repunched 5 #2 as a regular 1859 and I like the treasure hunt aspect of it.
P.S. Gidjit - If you ever decide to sell, let me know before you flood the market ...