If You Had To Choose One Of The Following;

I say the Half Cent. It's too pretty to let go!

Your chocolate is melting from the heatwave! Great effect! (Half dollar)

Both look nice, but I'd take the half dollar first.

I voted for the Half Cent. But with further information I could make a different choice.

If the Half Cent was $50 and the SL half was $300 ..knowing those numbers would help me make a better decision.

I like the Half Cent because I see very little .. if any wear. The half dollar looks very nice also, much better than my 1858.

When I am faced with a decision like this I try to reseach what it would cost to purchase a better example of the same coin.

I also look at what which is the better deal.

Lastly, I step back .. and try to decide which coin I would like in my collection and not want to upgrade it later.

I voted for the half. The originality of the piece just screams at you and the Half Cent looks too perfect to me.

Ed
ANA LM-3175

I'd go with the Seated Half

I'm a copper nut but, would have to go with the Half here.
The Half Cent IMO, has been recolored but, if the price was right, I would consider.