Best Way To Sell These Morgan And Peace Dollars

i would say the morgans and Peace dollars would go for $30 as well.. EXCEPT for the 1921 Peace dollar. that one you have there is RARE and depending on the grade would fetch possibly $100 or more.

also, the mint mark on the Peace dollars can be found on the reverse just below the word ONE

To be honest if you can find a dealer that will pay you spot for the common coins it may be best to go ahead and sell to them. You will skip the ebay and paypal fee's and you will not have to ship anything (if you ship free, so that would come out of my winnings as well) packaging material and the worry of it making it to the buyer which I worry about every time even though I have never had one lost myself but I ALWAYS use signature confirmation when selling a coin so the postal worker doesn't just leave it at the mail box or stick it in his pocket or drop it in the drain and instead of getting it out just say it was delivered. If I were to sell on ebay I may sell them in lots of 5 or so that way the package would be worth adding the signature confirmation to and less shipping material. I know others may disagree with this method because I usually sell higher priced coins on ebay myself (with a value of $200.00-$1500.00) and that is all I have to base my opinion on. The 1921 Peace dollar could be sold individually as it should bring close to the 100.00 range as was stated above. If you do go the ebay route be sure to take very good shots of each coin Obverse and Reverse (not a batch photo like you have above) because that may bring a whole different type of buyer in the fold called the VAM collector, with clear shots they can see what VAM the coin is and if it is one they want or need they will pay more than you would ever get out of the coin if it wasn't that VAM. So if you take a poor pi8cture where they can't make out the details to be able to attribute it then you will definitely get at the bottom of the value range for the coin.


This being said, I would like to see you post a better picture of that 1921-P Morgan in the first picture on the far right side. It looks like something on the rim of the Obverse around the "E" of E PLURIBUS and it may be a small Cud or some type of damage. WE have at least one 1921 VAMmer on this forum that may be able to tell you what VAM that one is and if it carries any premium over any other 1921 Morgan in that condition before you go to sell it

Id shop them around. If you have a local dealer it doesn't hurt to see what theyd offer. Almost always though youd get more money on ebay for them. With the fees you lose 13% but giving up 3.40ish on a 30 dollar sale is still better than accepting a 20 dollar offer from a dealer

I'd also run a magnet over all of them, too, and see if anything sticks.

Although the images are too low-quality to be sure, the middle 1923 Peace dollar in the second-to-last picture seems to be missing the bridge of Liberty's nose and has a very weak reverse which is a common sign for counterfeits of that year.

Also, could I see a bigger image of the mint mark on that 1900-O Morgan?

@steve- if you compare the reverse of that 1923S with its obverse, the wear is about the same, justifying the missing nose bridge. I dont think its counterfiet, but its too hard to tell from those pics anyway