Looks to me like another uneven strike on the reverse. Maybe this was just common back then. Certainly didn't have the technology we do now. 10-11 o'clock looks perfect, and 3-4 o'clock looks well worn. Judging by this I would go as high as AU-55, with I think the top of the star on the obverse being the limiting factor.
But, I still stink at this game, so hopefully someone with more experience in these comes along.
But, I still stink at this game, so hopefully someone with more experience in these comes along.






















