I'll chime in and say the second as well. The carbon spot on the obverse of the first just hurts it a bit in the eye appeal department.
Tough to say based on grade alone as they both have some pretty decent dings on the head/neck (cheek and under the nose on the first one and forehead/eye/neck on the second) but I bet they both could earn a 63.
Either way, that's still a coin I need to pick up for my Dansco and they are both very nice! Congrats!