Sorry for late response guys, but
Pertinax, I checked all the coins to make sure they were legit and not fakes, the two I got (will upload) were legit.
Tryna, by found he meant like he was cleaning out his shop and forgot he had them from someone pawning them who knows when and yeah he was thinking that I was trying to buy them as a collector (which I would have if they were in better condition/were rare)
Badtothebone,
Yeah I'm sticking to my guns and hopes he calls me back whenever he finds out that Franklins are not worth 20 a pop and that his 1921 Morgans aren't worth 50 a pop. He saw my wad of cash when I paid for the two dollars I got, I'm hoping that is something he will keep in mind (we met at a local starbucks so I felt pretty safe)