Redfield 1893-CC Morgan

If it really is an MS-65, then it's a splendid deal, the toning is really nice to boot. It's also redfield, so that adds to the value I guess.
I could see it as an easy 64, don't know if it will stretch to 65 or not.

If any of this coin's present or past owners had reason to believe that this coin would grade MS65 at one of the major TPG grading companies it would have been busted out of the Redfield holder a long time ago.

Most likely the coin would grade 63 with an outside chance at 64 if graded late Friday afternoon with the grading finalizer trying to get away for a date with his new girlfriend!

Most of the Redfield dollars I've seen over the years fall into the 62 to 64 real world grades. That "65" on the Paramount holder is wishful thinking .....for the most part.

MS-63, seems a bit pricy

Could well be, as that was one of the mistakes made in handling the hoard, and the 1893-CC was among those issues specifically noted to have been so marred. It suggests that if this example was submitted, it might come back "bodybagged" or with a "details" annotation for mechanical damage. In any case, there's significant risk, which makes the price all that much more daunting.