The shine is from the coins being photographed through a 2X2. I just cut them out and scanned them for the other pictures you see.
Yes, Dave, one of the key things to look at is the beads of the crown for helping grade these. Sometimes they're poorly struck and cannot be used to help ascertain the grade. However, when they look like you see, that's an indicator that the coin hasn't seen so much wear as to go into the Fine grade. Plus, look at how sharp the vertical lines are on the reverse, along with the wreath.