Reliable Internet Dealers

jbakic..... now you are on the right track, ebay is the place.

Build a relationship with a few ebay dealers with VERY POSITVE FEEDBACK. 100% to 99.7% is all I deal with.

errror

For what you're collecting, try:
www.harlanjberk.com
www.jjteaparty.com

They are both excellent for dealing with in all respects, and carry a very broad range of coins. Also, here's a few of my favorite dealers, both in person and online:
www.jaderarecoin.com
www.briangreer.com
www.dickosburn.com

They deal mostly in early type coins, though, so they may not have what you're looking for. Also try the major auction galleries, like Heritage, Superior, Stacks...

JB,

It really comes down to how well you educate yourself on the coins you're interested in. If you want to buy off the internet, then you need to look at a lot of pictures from Heritage Auctions (They only sell graded coins, so you know exactly what each coin is based on the slab it's in). They have soooo many coins you will never be able to see them all. Go to their archives to show what coins have sold in the past, and look at the various grades to see the differences. As you look at coins online you might want to buy, compare them side by side to some of the Heritage auctions (and remember, the prices include a 15% buyers premium, so divide the final price by 1.15 to see what the real bid was. This is closer to what you may see for graded coins on ebay.). You will be able to tell pretty quickly what quality of raw coin you are getting and if it's worth pursuing. I agree with Error on the feedback. Nothing under 99.7% sounds good to me. Also, go to https://www.toolhaus.org and put their screen name in there and you will find all the negative and neutral feedback they have received. This will tell you a lot about them. And, go through their postive feedback as well. Sometimes people put bad things in a positive feedback so they don't get a negative in retaliation from the seller. Also, if they don't have a decent picture up, then be careful. Ask for more pictures and see if they will send you better ones. Also watch out for people who say "I'm not a professional, but I think this would grade such and such". This is usually bull crap so watch out for that. You look at the coin and decide what you think the grade is.

I have bought all the coins I own off ebay. I know I overpaid for some of my ASE's, but at least I didn't spend a huge amount learning. And, they are still beautiful coins. I'm waiting for some raw coins to come back from NGC. Then I'll see how good (or bad!) I did on those.

One other thing, don't chase a coin that someone starts bidding up. There will always be another one. Auction fever can get you if you're not carful. You might want to try https://www.auctionsniper.com. You put in your maximum bid and at the last minute your bid goes in and many time you'll take it away from someone without having to pay your maximum. And, if it gets bid up past your maximium (that you set when you were rational ), you don't have to worry about trying to chase it and over pay for it.

Thanks for all the advise... I guess I was looking more for dealers that you folk have used that you trusted. I understand the used car salesman Carl. Guido thanks for the advice, I knew about Toolhaus, but didn;t think to compare to Heritage Auctions for comparisons...You guys are all great.

Opps! Thanks, Ceaton. I made the correction. I have it as a favorite and just click on it.

Some I like that haven't already been listed:

www.briangreerrarecoins.com
www.allensinc.com
www.wscoins.com

It's great that you guys share your knowledge. Thanks.