Before reading your second post, that is exactly I was thinking when I pulled it up. It's not as obvious on the 1909 S, but the pitting on the 14 D looking very characteristic of a cast. It was also obvious that the details on the obverse were much weaker than the reverse. Despite the fact that I know very little about identifying fake key date coins (and I've never attempted to buy one at that), I can tell very well they can't be real.




















