Thanks for the opinions. To add to this thread I will explain why I think they are fake. The rim should fade near the clip but these have a full rim all the way to the clip. I'm not able to see any metal flow toward the clip (weakness in the design, letters or numbers). I don't see any Blakesley effect, but it is possible for a true clip not to have this. More importantly on these coins there is metal on the clipped edge that is folded over on the 1934 and metal that is pushed up on the 1918. Unfortunately there are bids on these coins and it appears they will be sold to some unsuspecting numismatics.