I would agree that the two errors are unrelated. The obverse definitely has some sort of peripheral die damage, but I hesitate to characterize it as either collar clash or a die attrition error. I suppose it could be damage from colliding with the top of the collar (a form of collar clash), but the thin, arcing ridges are not entirely consistent with that scenario.
It looks like the poorly-struck areas could be either a grease strike or a slightly weak strike. In either case, it looks like the poor strike has revealed a slightly cracked surface. If so, we're looking at a planchet error. These superficial cracks might have been smoothed-out by the strike in other areas.
It looks like the poorly-struck areas could be either a grease strike or a slightly weak strike. In either case, it looks like the poor strike has revealed a slightly cracked surface. If so, we're looking at a planchet error. These superficial cracks might have been smoothed-out by the strike in other areas.
Error coin writer and researcher.






























