Keep These Or Send Back?

Did you buy them as proofs or to stack silver? If the latter and they were purchased at a good price, the spots won't matter. Otherwise send them back, in my generally inexpert opinion.

Id send em back. I never had bu eagles look like that stacked or not.

I think it largely depends on the circumstances. You need to provide more information. Am I correct to assume that you bought them sight unseen? Who did you buy them from, a major bullion reseller or an individual? Did you buy them as new out of the tube or impaired? Do they have different dates for a collection or are they for stacking silver? Is there any other information you can provide?

Bought them from provident for my stack. I've decided to keep them because I'd have to pay the return shipping & also,provident judges whether you can exchange them. You have to them pics of each coin &mthen they decide which one you can return. I've now read three other posts of people with similar problems with on sale items from provident. Sounds like they're pulling out all the less than perfect coins,which are technically still bu & throwing those up for sale when dips happen. Shady.

Note to self: avoid Provident.

Lylelovett666, did Provident tell you that you'd have to pay shipping back to them? The reason that I ask is that JM Bullion sent me a prepaid shipping label to return a blemished 5oz ATB to them. I also recently received one that had a cracked capsule. They offered for me to return it at their expense or send another capsule if they could find one. I elected the latter and the lady I spoke with called me back the next day to let me know that they found a capsule. She even called me back a few days later to make sure that I had received the replacement capsule. The point here is that since JM was so good about returning blemished coins, Provident might be too since they compete against each other.

I'd call and argue for a return label. To me, those are impaired. If they refuse, post some bad reviews with pictures.