RCM May New Coin Release

I went to the RCM site and couldn't see any of those coins. UFOcoin posted a link on ebay - thanks.

Great.

@vonigohcr: Thanks much for the additional details on the SE Proof Set.

I'm not generally a fan of painted coins, but my "obsession" with keeping my SD set complete will win out and I will purchase the set. At least the set won't be too expensive - I was thinking it was going to be a full silver set with a price tag of $234.95. The 2016 base metal set was $99.95 - hopefully, this 2018 base metal set will be the same price.

@vonigohcr:

The SD and the gold $100 coins are definitely the most traditional of the RCM commemorative coin series. "Congrats!" on the assembly of two great collections that commemorate Canadian history.

I've considered buying the SD from the various proof sets as a standalone coin in the secondary market vs. continuing to buy the full sets from the RCM - it would definitely save some money! So far, however, I've kept up with full-set orders from the RCM.

I think a big factor for me is the potential that the single coin was mishandled during its transfer out of the proof set packaging and that the problem(s) (e.g., a fingerprint) would not show until months down the line (after the return window is closed). It's probably a small risk, but it is in the back of my mind each time.

If the RCM continues to increase the number of SD sets it issues each year and also continues to increase their issue price, I may have to change my way of thinking!

I'd really like to get an inexpensive (less than $100) coin commemorating the end of WWI. Thoughts on if the armistice coin is likely to be the best quality one in this price range?

Maybe I would go to $150 for this particularly topic.

@zoziw: While I think the newly-released silver dollar commemorating the centennial of WWI Armistice Day is a well-designed and attractive coin, I agree with Electrum that it is very likely that additional coins with the same theme are likely to be released as the actual anniversary date nears. If you are only going to purchase one coin, you might want to wait to see what other designs come along.

I purchased the Armistice SD, but SDs are my collecting niche - I didn't need to wait to see what else might be coming!

I know things have been a bit slow around here (except for the Falcon Lake and Captain Canuck coins), but I'm a little surprised that essentially all of May's releases are going without discussion.

Here are a few of my thoughts that I hope will generate some discussion:

I purchased the Armistic SD and the SE Proof set to keep my SD collection complete. I think the Armistice SD design is a strong one; I'm less pleased with the colourized SD in the SE Proof Set. I always prefer engraved coins vs. painted. Selective gold-plating on engraved design elements works for me, but applying paint to flat surfaces on a coin is far less interesting. Hopefully, I will be pleasantly surprised when my set arrives.

I always enjoy seeing unadopted coin designs brought to life, so the three-piece "Coin Lore" set is intriguing. The set appears to be well-executed. I'm tempted, but resisting.

The gold-plated silver Borealia coin has its merits. It was designed by the same artist (Rebecca Yanovskaya) that was responsible for last year's "150th Anniversary of Canadian Confederation" allegorical SD. IMO, the new design of the allegorical figure is stronger than the one on last year's coin. I might be tempted at some point.

The new batch of SML 30th anniversary coins is another example of overkill IMO. How many different coins are needed to commemorate a coin from just 30 years ago. I've never been a fan of the maple leaf-shaped coins, but have no issue with those that do. We each need to collect what we enjoy!

I wonder if the T-Rex coin will gain any traction? The extreme close-up offers an interesting perspective. One Kg of silver makes for an expensive coin, however - especially with the RCM strong markup! With only 400 available, it has a chance to eventually sell out but I just don't know about the market for such a piece. Will it soon fade into obscurity? Not a coin for me, but I hope some are pleased with it.

Last year's Dragon Boat Festival coin definitely generated more interest and discussion. It appears this year's model is a non-starter for most. I'd be interested in hearing about the quality of the colorization from someone who purchased the piece (or has seen one in person). The video on the RCM (YouTube) site seems to show nice colour saturation.


What thoughts do you have about the May release?

Would like to discuss commems but you said it all. I can't add much as you hit the key points on the full release.

I did order the Armistice SD and the Cabot Cook SD from earlier this year but those are my only NCLT purchases so far in 2018.

edited for brain cramp

First of all - congrats on the nice coin, YesOrNo

It looks great.

I like all the masks theme, but feel that having 2015 set is enough, as "summarizing the topic". Except this, I like "carved" and not painted design.
(this only imho, your coin is cool).




Regarding to above:
The RCM minted coins, packs it and put in the bin. So first minted will be in the bottom, and last on the top. You ordered on the first day, so employee took the case from the top (with the high Serial Number) and sent to you.

well, this is nice explain, but most likely incorrect
The COA attached randomly to the case with coin, by the special "COA-inserter" employee