Since I only collect Newfoundland coins, I can only grade this the way Newfoundland coins are graded.
I don't see any luster. It is a nice coin, true, but due to the surface chatter, weak strike (weak band) and rim dings I would hold this one at VF-30. Official grading at a TGP could net a VF-AU grade, but not worth the fees imo - no
TPG service is worth its salt - if they won't provide explanations for the grade and descriptions of the coin, what is the point in having someone else's opinion which may or may not be as good as my own?