1968 D Kennedy Half Looks Like Proof - Help Needed

Images from PCGS "Coinfacts"
1968-D
https://images.PCGS.com/CoinFacts/4...498_2200.jpg

1968-S Proof:
https://images.PCGS.com/CoinFacts/4...049_2200.jpg
When you click on the images, not the fields of the coins. The proof one has a lot more shine on the fields.

On you two images, the use of the light is the same on both images. Using the pen color would be more convincing if the pen was used on the same side of the images. Placing the coin vertically rather than horizontally. Then the pen differences could be seen better. This could be taken in two shots. On the second shot you could place the second coin on the top of the other coin, thus the locations would be the same? The more you start illustrating coins, the quicker ideas will come to you. Look at how others place them, then see if you could think if a better solution to a problem. Then use what pluses work for the better. I'm still coming up with new solutions for old problems. I find my self looking at the setups on the shows and see what they are doing and how I could think up a different way to create illustrations. My mind is always working. (sometimes hard to shut it down)

Hi again,

I do not know if this is better? My lighting is always left wanting, my apologies.

However, I took a pic of the rims again. If they are both 40% silver, why does the "shiny" one's edge look like it may be fully clad?

Thank you very much Coop. Please find pictures below: