1930-S Please Help Grade Sent In Raw Was ANACS MS-64 Red

Looks like there's enough red to carry RD. Reverse has a nice strike...obverse is a little weak (lds)?
I think he crossed 64RD
smat

Let's see if I understand.
It was in an ANACS holder at MS-64 RD.
You cracked it out and sent it to another TPG (PCGS?).
It came back at a lower grade and/or color.
Now you're unhappy.

Is this correct?

[quote]Let's see if I understand.
It was in an ANACS holder at MS-64 RD.
You cracked it out and sent it to another TPG (PCGS?).
It came back at a lower grade and/or color.
Now you're unhappy.

Yes I cracked it out of a ANACS holder that had the coin at MS-64 red. I want all PCGS holders. The consensus on the forum in the past was that you had better luck if you cracked and resubmitted raw to get an upgrade ( I have read this in past threads on different forums whether that's true or not. I have read several times that PCGS rarely upgrades what they consider a lower tier grading companys' coin. They will cross at same grade or lower more often than not if they even cross at all. I don't know if that's true or not. The coin looked better than a 64 in the holder.. Once cracked , I realized that I may have made a mistake. Something I will do many more times in the future.. My best learning tools are my mistakes and don't repeat them. I will reveal the results later tonight. On 10 crack outs I had one third tier company that will surprise you. One company was dead on with PCGS. I did not crack and coins from NGC.

The reverse is very nice!

64RD

Excellent, the reverse moved it up IMO.