thanks for your thoughts everyone. the pictures dont do it justice. its very smooth and attractive in hand. the color of the coin makes it look like it might be micro porous but it isn't.
this is a common variety and we are solidly outside condition census range.
i have this one graded at EAC VF 25 no net and call it average+. my pops and Dennis Loring, who the coin came from, both graded 25 no net as well. I think it would slab at 35 and has a shot to make 40.