Well ... if you're still dealing with only the "concrete" covering the surface of the coin, anything will do. I use an old Swiss army knife to take off the top layers of dirt, shaving it off in layers. But once you expose the surface of the coin, those microscopic particles of dirt act like fine-grit sandpaper, and a toothbrush will just grind them across the surface and remove the patina and even particles of bronze. I'd even be careful with a toothpick when you expose the surface. The key is to be patient and let the coin soak, soak, soak so that the dirt comes off easily. I've been soaking one of my coins for several years now!