This is a hard question. In my opinion .....
When putting away
State Quarters... the ones that will have value in the future
will be the very high grade examples. MS66 or better.
In my experience the mint rolls have better quality coins.
I have bought many mint rolls at or near face value.
I do believe there are some rolls that are harder to find and are trading
above face value. In my experience the hard ones are
P and D rolls - GA, CT, TN and IL
If it helps grey sheet has Bid roll prices (Feb,25 CDN)
GA - P $22.00, GA - D $24.00
CT - P $20.00, CT - D $21.00
TN - P $24.00, TN - D $33.00
IL - P $32.00, IL - D $38.00
You asked about CA and OH
CA - P $16.50, CA - D $18.00
OH - P $18.00, OH - D $18.00
I think that some of the roll prices are higher, because it is hard to find
certain states in higher grade. And some are just harder to find, like IL,
because a lot of IL quarters were used to make Obama coins.
I do have to say that most dealers do not want to purchase rolls of state
quarters.