What I really need to do is to get a good look at some
high AU/MS coins with varying degrees of luster to get
a better idea. I see there is quite a diff. in premium between
AU50 and 58. Having the coin in hand (which makes a world of difference) I cannot see anything under an AU58 details on this coin. Even a few years ago when I first saw this coin
i was not even thinking AU period but trying to decide whether
it was a 61 or 62 (detail wise)
I'm at odds lately with the
TPG's. Not happy with there ups and downs and labeling etc. Not much sense wasting money on it
if it comes back AU50. Guess I will let the prospective buyer be the judge. I have no emotional attachment to this coin so
anyones opinion does not reflect on me. Nor does it deflect :)
To me it looks like a very very nice coin. Like what a coin is supposed to look like almost 150 yrs. later if it was taken care of properly and not exposed to circulation. Maybe not drop dead gorgeous with tons of makeup and fancy jewelry (luster) but a gently aged well looker :)