The last one has a good chance to be a fake. I wouldn't play with it (avoid philipines, even more when it's private auctions and when the coin looks dodgy).
Coinworldtv has nice coins, already bought some from him. I had that one in my watch list as well, but didn't picked it because of the hole :)
Gosh, we will be both looking for the same coins, I hope we won't end over-bidding each other :p
Or maybe actually not, as I am looking for a Carolus III 4 reales, and you are looking for a philippus V one :)
Got one recently from the latest Soler y Llach auction :

Coinworldtv has nice coins, already bought some from him. I had that one in my watch list as well, but didn't picked it because of the hole :)
Gosh, we will be both looking for the same coins, I hope we won't end over-bidding each other :p
Or maybe actually not, as I am looking for a Carolus III 4 reales, and you are looking for a philippus V one :)
Got one recently from the latest Soler y Llach auction :





















