What's The Future Of The 2019-S Enhanced Reverse Proof ASE

It'll remain always the lowest production Heraldic Eagle ASE. In the future, I think that really is significant. I see it as potentially being worth more than the 95W. Those with Proof 70s with a certified matching and the early signed COA, are sitting on solid gold. And this coming from an OGP collector.

I have 2 of them. They are being held as a "speculative investment", I think long term the value will go up, maybe not as high as the 1995 W but close enough. The big difference between the 2 is the 2019 S ERP was better released so many different collectors have them, the 1995 W was limited to collectors that could afford gold , it had a limited release. Long term value isn't built in a year or 2, give the 2019 S ERP about 20-30 years and it should be worth a few $$$$.

The major thing for it is that its only one of the 2 Enhanced Reverse Coin.

But to keep the eye candy the full set of 2019....

The 5% Annually sounds about right. Being a Lower Mintage I too would of thought it would be A Higher Valued Coin, as stated prior, It should Continue to go up Also, PS, The 2018 Red Book shows the 1995-W 10TH Anniversary set @ $6,800. EDITED to correct the Price, Sorry. Over $2,000.00 in 5 years, According to the book.


The 2023 Red Book shows the 1995 -W set @ $9,000

The 2023 Red Book shows the 2019-S ERP @$1,200 Let's see what it goes to in 5 years.... I predict $2500-$3,000

Eagle,

Really, I believe the 95 -W has a Strong Rising Value, Especially, As Noted, With the GOLD Since 2018, the price has gone Up...

2023 Red Book values the 95-W Silver Eagle @ $4,000.

Do they say any particular grade or is that raw? I'd imagine that's about the price for a 69. When I got my set the price for the ASE was calculated at way less than that, then he factored it the gold value. That came out to about what I had been expecting to buy the complete set for.

I based my response on graded 95 W's sales, because finding an ungraded 95 W being sold raw, as an individual purchase, is pretty tough. That said, I did some further research, which I was too lazy to do when I first responded.

I realize Red Book is just a retail price guide. I don't know how Red Book can assign such a value when evaluating the silver 95 W on it's own, especially at $4,000.00, likewise have the entire set @ $9,000.00.

Keep this in mind when reading on. Gold is up roughly 8% from August 2021, silver on the other hand remained flat, for the same period. Also, the sell price of the examples below are within $300.00 of each other.

A recent sale on 3/14/23 on the bay, a full 5 coin proof set sold for $6,900.00. If you separate the gold from the silver, at today's bullion price, the gold alone without margin attached, comes out to roughly $3,700.00 +/-, add a very modest seller margin of 25%, you're up to $4,900.00 +/-, that leaves the silver 95 W at $2,000.00.

Looking at 3 major auction houses that I can access, Heritage, DL and SB, over the last 3 years, one full set was purchased raw that I found. That set sold through SB for $7,200.00 in August 2021. Gold was around $1810.00 +/- at the time. Assuming similar margin as above, this puts the gold at $4,465.00, leaving the silver 95 W at $2,736.00.

So, in this comparison, the silver 95 W value has fallen. I find similar on graded silver 95 W Eagles. I have no clue how or when PCGS and NGC update the current average value, but they are currently at $20,250.00. Over the last 3 years of 15 sold individual Silver Eagles, through Heritage, SB and D. Lawrence, the realized average comes out to $17,387.00, these all include some type of buyer premiums.

Maybe I'm not looking at it right and I'm open to suggestions. Lord knows, I don't want this to be true for owners of the 95 W. Maybe what this shows is we're coming out of the COVID buying spree.

Thank you MD!


Just a SWAG here but, if population figures are to be believed, out of the 30,000 figures on each years minting, totaling both services grade reports, the 95 W PF 70 grades at a rough rate of 30 ish %, where the 2019 S grades at a rate of 60 ish %. In 3 1/2 - 4 years, the 2019 S already has more than double at grade 70, than the 95 W has at 70, in 28 years. Surely the lower % at 70 grade will command a larger premium. Who am I to say what the premium should be. All I know is, this may be the only ASE I would not pursue at PF 70, unless I win the lottery of course.

@MD, yes, I thought that's what I was saying.