1890 CC Twenty Dollars Gold

The first photos hide whatever luster it has. They also minimize the hairline scratches. The Photobucket shots show some obvious diagonal hairlines on the obverse which are most likely evidence of an abrasive cleaning. The Photobucket reverse shot does show some luster, enough I would think to qualify for an AU-50 details grade.

Strike seems a bit weak, particularly on some of the obverse stars and the rays below STATES. The mintmark letters appear filled. These features could be normal and the coin genuine. Or, they might be indicators that the coin is a fake. That potential is why this piece should indeed be certified to confirm authenticity. If it is real I would expect it to grade as Genuine at PCGS or AU Details, cleaned at NGC or ANACS. Since it likely won't slab problem-free I would probably go with ANACS since they are excellent for authentication, you don't need to join any club, and the cost will be a bit less.

For comparison, here are photos of my 1890-CC $20 coin which I purchased as an NGC AU-55 and later crossed it to PCGS at the same grade. A quick comparison with your coin does not show any obvious differences in date or lettering which are places that counterfeiters often screw up. Hopefully your coin is genuine and your chosen grading service will confirm that fact. Carson City gold is special, no matter the grade or date. Enjoy!

Aye that is. :-)

@nileshcvtech - Actually, more importantly, in this photobucket image:

http://i1159.photobucket.com/albums...DSC_0194.jpg

Are those two dings that look like bumps on Liberty's lower lip raised or incused?

Jaobler thanks for posting your 1890 CC photos. That's a beautiful coin you have :)


Steve the two dings look as if they are incused when I checked using a loupe.

Thanks everyone. I appreciate all your valuable thoughts.