Posted 07/02/2012 11:55 am
Mind you, we take the above post as a joke, whihch is why the poster is not in orbit yet. 
None of these gold coins strike me as huge rarities due to low mintages; if circulated, chances are they'll be worth (generally) melt value. There may be specific ones which have turned out to be rarer than expected in the real world due to circulation or meltage - I have to leave that specific area to others more knowledgeable of gold.
The same goes for the silver dollars, an area where I'm more comfortable, with two exceptions. If Peace dollars rather than Morgans, the 1921's will have additional value, as will the 1928 Peace. These would be relatively high priorities for you to post images if the 1921's are Peace dollars. The possibility also exists that they may be of a more-collectible variety - Morgans and Peace dollars have a following who collect by variety - but very few of these varieties have additional value in a circulated example.
None of these gold coins strike me as huge rarities due to low mintages; if circulated, chances are they'll be worth (generally) melt value. There may be specific ones which have turned out to be rarer than expected in the real world due to circulation or meltage - I have to leave that specific area to others more knowledgeable of gold.
The same goes for the silver dollars, an area where I'm more comfortable, with two exceptions. If Peace dollars rather than Morgans, the 1921's will have additional value, as will the 1928 Peace. These would be relatively high priorities for you to post images if the 1921's are Peace dollars. The possibility also exists that they may be of a more-collectible variety - Morgans and Peace dollars have a following who collect by variety - but very few of these varieties have additional value in a circulated example.
mdrowe. The list of coins that you describe as "good" are probably a lot better than numismatic good. A coin that grades good is very worn and near the bottom of the 1-70 scale. I saw your post on the 1906 20 dollar gold. It is actually an "S" mint coin in what appears to be mint state condition (possibly somewhere in the 61-64 range). Worth considerably more than melt value. If the other coins on your list are comparable to this one you have quite a stash. Pictures of the front and back of each coin down to the 1935 dollar would help folks here determine what you have from a value standpoint.
(Sorry, been holding that in since your first post).
The guys here will really be able to help with them.
