1931-S Value?

Looks higher than VG8 from what I can tell. Take it out of the holder and get better pictures. Yes, it's been harshly cleaned. Value will be greatly reduced.

Still Like It!!

A problem coin will always be a problem coin ... IMHO this example has very limited value to any collector.

David

Looks like XF detail on the obverse. Value might be VG though. Probably $60 or so.

probably around 60 - 70 dollars. This is what I sell problem 1931 s for.

Problem is, so far as I've experienced, some people know that they shouldn't clean coins yet will anyway. Reason being, that's how they like their coins to look, and they plan on holding on to them. Then later they decide to sell, and learn what a big mistake they made. In some cases they may pass away and their relatives make the sell. Sad thing is, really desirable coins get the same treatment as not so much desirable ones. I think it's extremely sad that your 1931S got that treatment. I own some cleaned coins that I got deals on. As far as value goes, it really only matters what you think it's value is vs what you paid. (until you go to sell it) So with that, I hope you got it for a bargain and are pleased with it. After all, it only matters that you're happy !!

I really like your example of the acetone bath. I have several penny coins I purchased at a local show and they have that glossy look. I have also tried acetone but with no luck. The coin always seems to turn a odd color. You had great results. Can you explain just a little more what type of acetone you use? Bought mine at a local hardware store and also how long you leave it in the acetone. Do you do anything else after taking it out other then letting it dry? Thanks very much for any reply.

Try the Acetone and then allow to sit on a kitchen window sill for a while.