The "Technology of Silver-Plated Coin Forgeries" by Susan LaNiece is certainly
one of the most important papers presented in Metallurgy in Numismatics 3. Just
have some comments on some statements she made during this paper which is over 20
years old. At the time it was an INCREDIBLE paper but some correction in 2013
are in order:
LaNiece: Silver Foil - They have a copper or copper alloy flan encased in a
silver foil.
JPL: Yes - I agree. From the examples in my World CC data base most early silver
foil pieces are over a copper alloy rather than the later Sheffield - Birmingham
silver plated pieces which are over brass type alloy which exhibit better
bonding as hundreds exist in NGC/PCGS holders for these CC8R's. The coins over
copper will tend to peel easier as the eutectic alloy interface will be stronger
with Ag/Brass than Ag/Cu. We see this phenomenon with the U.K. Commonwealth
Silver plated over copper forgeries showing MASSIVE peeling.
LaNiece: The use of mercury silvering is less widespread (than silver plating).
P.230.
JPL: This is totally INCORRECT. We find actually going from medieval times to
the 18th/19thC time period we find mercuric silvering as the counterfeiting
method of choice. It was LaNiece's narrow focus (my opinion - as all these
Metallurgy in Numismatic articles were predominantly of ancient - focused) that
she made a statement like like this since you will be very hard pressed to find
a 1700 or 1800 world CC's that have been silver plated rather than being Hg
silvered (amalgamation process). The exception are the CC8Rs produced in
Birmingham using the Sheffield ware type process by
The Royal Mint when at war
with Spain at this time.
LaNiece: Cliche-type forgeries: Those coins differ from those described above in
that they have a soft white metal core of tin and/or lead rather than copper or
brass.
JPL: Vey difficult to find. Do not own one? She mentioned a 15thC groat,
sixpence of Elizabeth I, two 17thC brass tokens and two George I farthings dated
1721 & 1724. I have not verified a silver plated tin or lead World CC. I own
white metal (Sb/Sn/Pb), High Sn and Sb/Pb type alloys but no silver plated tin
or lead examples. Not sure if this is a category? Need more data or assistance?
Perhaps seen in ancient period or a miss-classification.
LaNiece: Tinning.
JPL: Still to find a tin plated brass specimen. She discusses a 15thC penny of
tin-plated brass. Again - a fragmented category with no substance from my
research. Send me a tin plated bi-layer CC - PLEASE.
This paper is valuable to introduce the student to silver plating with some
excellent discussion of silver/copper bonding temperatures and microstructure
pictures of this interface.
I reach the same basic conclusions when discussing the silver/brass interface in
the Three Coin Paper for the CC8R Birmingham, England Sheffield.
John Lorenzo
United States