'Double Die' is a term that Charlton introduced a few years ago to denote a die with a letter or number that is doubled (the doubling usually caused by double puching or repunching). I find the terminology confusing since it is so close to the term 'Doubled Die' which means that the die was subjected to 'Hub doubling' during its creation.
Recut is a loose term that Zoell came up with that usually means the die was manually altered to correct an imperfection and which resulted in a doubled appearance. The clear outlines tht are exhibited on R444e are, to my mind, too cleancut to be a result of such die rework. The doubled three appears to be the result of the '3' number punch being struck into the die in an offset manner (twice offset from the main image) ... As an aside, the last two digits of the date for the 1941 - 1949 George VI 50 cent dies were all hammer punched into the dies.
When reading the Zoell catalogues, realize that they were early days of variety classificaion and some of the defintions are NOT examples of clarity. Later authors such as Alan Herbert have refined and widened the descriptions of the mechanisms of variety creation. Don't get me wrong, I admire Zoells works and they are what got me into coin varieties, but quite often they need some creative interpretation. Recut and re-entry are two such terms.
Edited by pginrh
11/24/2014 08:37 am