What Coin Should I Collect Next?

Do you have a time frame you want to complete it in? Do you have a grade for the coins you would like to stick with for the set?

I am going my own way. Essentially, I am a type collector.

For U.S. coins, I am doing a gold denomination set, within each denomination my favorite type.
My next target is an Indian head half eagle.

(A sub collection, which is part of my World coin collection)

Flip a coin, heads is one choice, tails is the second choice and if perchance it lands on the edge it is the third choice.

It is your collection, you are the one paying for it and looking at it if you cannot decide what you want then do not do anything until you can make up YOUR own mind. Asking what to collect next or conducting a poll on any forum will get you nowhere as each member has their own preferences for their coin collections so the point of this thread is useless to help you figure out what to do.

I prefer type coin collecting in AU and better condition and do not give a hoot about what anyone else thinks about what types of coins I collect. Some people are content with collecting lower graded coins or higher graded coins and that is quite okay since coin collecting is a very personal choice and I do not judge other collectors by the types/grades of coins they collect. You collect what makes YOU happy.

I agree with everybody...indian head cents !

I would say Indian Head cents because you won't need to buy different size flips.

Do you have any other sets going or completed?
When silver prices were so high in the recent past, I worked on and
completed a set of Jeffersons. I started out merely liking the Jeffs, but
quickly fell in love. It can be an easy set in most respects, but can be
challenging at times to put together a set with lots of eye appeal.

For this case, and using the choices that are given, I am voting for the
Buffalo nickels... However, I would do the nickels AND the Franklins. The
reason being that the Franklin is far from a rare coin, and even in unc
condition, almost all dates are tied to the price of silver, more than the
actual collector value of the coin. So, when silver prices are up, you can
build your Buffalo collection and avoid overpaying for the common silver
halves. When silver prices are down, splurge and stock up on nice halves.
The Franklin set is so short too, that doing it this way, you can still
build your set relatively quick. Just remember that silver has ranged from
$5 to nearly $50 an ounce in only the last 15 years, and historically has
followed this pattern many times over and over in the past. So you will have
to be the one to make the "call" as to when you are comfortable buying up
silver coins to fill your set, and when the price goes up to the point where
you build your Buffalo set. IMO, doing it this way is the "smart way" and
can stretch both your budget and enjoyment to the maximum returns. Make sense?

I recommend Franklin halves. This series will not be hard on your budget. I HAVE to also suggest Eisenhower dollars. Fun. Fun. Fun.