A post from the owner of the Libertas medal (ats) regarding this episode......this should answer your questions.
Quote: I missed the episode last night, but I'll watch it online when I can. I was invited to be part of the filming, but work deadlines prevented that; otherwise, I would have gladly been there!
Jeff Garrett is one of the experts that gets brought in to evaluate numismatic items for the show. For this specific episode, Jeff was looking for both a
Half Disme and a Libertas medal, and Jeff was able to locate them and had the respective owners' permission to have them appear on the show. The
Half Disme is pedigreed to the Garrett Collection, and the silver Libertas medal was one that Jeff Garrett had sold some years back. (This particular Libertas medal has been in the Cardinal Collection for the past 6 years.)
Regarding the valuation of the silver Libertas medal in MS61, the piece needs to be regraded, as it is far superior to the other MS61-graded examples. I would call it MS62, or MS62+. The valuation of $200K came from me, and Walter Husak relayed that to Jeff Garrett. Yes, there are a number known in grades of 63 and 64, but this particular piece is one of just 3 known from the earliest state of the dies. That places it as definitely included in the first group of silver medals delivered to Benjamin Franklin on April 4th, 1783, and each of those were personally presented by Franklin himself to its original VIP recipient. These were truly the diplomatic presentation pieces -- and "First Strikes" at that! Following that first delivery, the Paris Mint struck additional batches for Franklin, but then in later years, several more pieces were struck at the request of others who simply wanted one. For example, the magnificent piece in George Washington's medal set was struck sometime around 1790, after Franklin had already returned to the United States, when Thomas Jefferson took over Franklin's role.
During the show, the
Half Disme was a no-sale. The Libertas medal was shown as sold at $150K on camera. That being said, the piece was not actually sold, even though Rick actually did want to buy it for $150K.