Actual Proof Buffalo Or A Whizzed MS?

if anything, its polished, I dont see evidence of whizzing.

definitely suspicious

It is hard to say from the photos, at least from my perspective. I would say it isn't whizzed. It looks proof to me...but like AdamE, I'm a little suspicious. Seller does have a return policy, however.

I bought a 1915 nickel certified by PCI as a matte proof PR-64. I've tried to cross it at both PCGS and ANACS with a minimum grade of PR-63 and both refused to put it in their plastic. I have considered breaking it out and submitting it raw but then it might be judged an ordinary business strike worth hundreds less than my (theoretical) slabbed matte proof.

I think the confirmation of proof status for these coins is very tricky and even advanced collectors can be reluctant to make that call. Paying proof money for a raw coin like this ebay example seems risky to the point of foolishness.

When I have a chance I'll post images of my 1915. I put it up some time ago but I'd be interested in any new CCF member opinions.

I agree. The lines around the devices were a give away for me. I would believe it was light, if it weren't visible from all angles of the coin.

Keep in mind what was said here, though, and what you saw. I *might* be wrong, but there will always be another coin. Numismatics is about knowledge and more importantly, patience.

Keep in mind, Paleoguy45, that as a Moderator I have to think of a bigger picture. Your thread has only eleven posts (counting the one I'm posting), and over 140 reads. A lot of people we never hear from read what's written here, and for them I will always overstate the obvious - I think you didn't *need* to hear a word posted here to make the right decision - by way of addressing those who are just accumulating knowledge without feeling the need to participate.

I know that will sometimes make Moderator posts seem a little overbearing or condescending, but that is absolutely not our intent. We're playing to the broader audience.

As promised, here are photos of my PCI-certified matte proof 1915 nickel, graded PR-64. Actual proof strike, or really sharp MS? How can you tell for sure? I don't know!