Gorgeous Half Dime On The Bay.

I'm pretty certain it's legit target toning.

every coin I have purchased in those NNC holders have had rim bumps that would keep the coin from grading problem free at any of the big three, so I quit purchasing any of them. One was the super DMPL VAM-70 that if not for the rim problems would probably have been the best of the best but I ended up selling it practically for about 10 dollars over melt. That was the final straw for me because that was the 4th or 5th coin I found to have problems hidden by the holder. If the coins didn't have problems then they would have been a good deal but with the problems the holders were hiding I certainly over paid for all of them

this is the coin I was talking about that had rim dings (actually looked like someone cut into the coin on the edge with something). It was a beautiful coin until it was cracked out, and once cracked out to find the problems, there is no returning it. If you look above and to the left of the are in PLURIBUS you can barely see where the problem is

The 1858 Seated Liberty half dollar graded AU-58 by PCGS in my 7070 album was cracked out of its slab and upon removing it I found it had a number of rim dings which were hidden by the holder. I was quite surprised that PCGS would grade a coin as such without mentioning the rim dings.

Ed
ANA LM-3175

Bryan you can always return stuff if you suspect the seller scammed you, just don't admit to ebay you removed it from the holder and they'll give you your money back. Did you buy it from centles or whatever?