| Author |
Replies: 21 / Views: 7,380 |
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
1189 Posts |
How are the Whitman folders vs the albums? I have some common collections I'd like to organize (clad quarters,dimes, halves). Would folders be ok to preserve the coins? For the higher valued collections (Mercury, silver Roosevelt), would folders be beter? I assume danscos are only for high valued stuff. Lastly is wizard coin the best place to buy this stuff from? Thanks!
|
|
|
|
Moderator
 United States
56855 Posts |
Albums are almost always better then folders and Dansco is probably the best. John1 
|
|
Pillar of the Community
 United States
1189 Posts |
Well an album is $17 while a folder is $3. For circulated clad, is the folder sufficient? Will it secure the coins or will they fall out? I can't justify paying the difference for an album unless a folder is junk and can't be used. For the nicer sets I think an album may be better though.
|
|
Rest in Peace
United States
7075 Posts |
But I have a Whitman album because I like the color better. I have a quarter collection and the silver looks better in the blue album. I keep most of my coins in Saflips in the notebook-sized pages so that I can arrange and re-arrange them any way I want.
|
|
Valued Member
United States
424 Posts |
It all depends on what you have and what you want. When I was a YN I used the old blue Whitman folder because I didn't know better and there wasn't much else available. Now I keep most of my collection in dansco albums, why? Two reasons:
Reason one, dansco albums are the best. You can view both sides of the coin without removing them and for the most part they preserve the coins very well.
Reason two, I like the look of dansco albums. For my taste I think the brown and tan showcase the coins at their best.
What does the value of the coins have to do with any of this? Very little in my opinion. I have a Dansco #8104 album, this is the Lincoln Sheild cents with proofs. It has two pages, one with dates and one simply titled Lincolns cents. It is up to date with coins from mint and proof sets. On a really good day the 21 coins in it may have a value of about a buck, the album cost me $17. I don't care about the value/cost ratio, this is how I want to store my coins and that is the only thing that really matters.
|
|
Bedrock of the Community
United States
11951 Posts |
Albums are preferred over folders. Albums will protect your coins better than folders. But if you are talking just circulated coins, no keys or semi key coins, folders work fine. In my opinion common circulated coins will never have a high value. I have seen some nice collections that were all in folders. Either albums or folders, they need to be kept in a controlled environment. Here is a folder that has had coins in it for over 50 years.   But albums are my favorite   Sometimes the coins are very hard to put into folders, and sometimes a couple coins will fall out when you open the folders. Another worry is some of the folders have glue residue on the back side, that can damage coins. This is part of keeping them in a humidly controlled environment. Wizard is a good source for coin supplies. Another is coin shops and coin shows, sometimes they have good used folders and albums at very low prices. If I find older folders in good shape, I like to pick them up. I think they are part the of history of coin collecting, and welcome additions to my collection. Like these ...  
|
|
Bedrock of the Community
United States
20753 Posts |
Quote:
Reason two, I like the look of dansco albums. For my taste I think the brown and tan showcase the coins at their best. Possibly the worst reason to use Dansco. So many say they look like an expensive book and then have to hide them away. Leaving any coin collection out in the open is just to risky. Almost any Album made today is about the same. Similar materials and similar methods of production so if looks is a major concern, think about where you have them stored. Some of the major problems with using a Folder is the method of how coins are placed in them. Most people push the coins into the slots with their thumbs or fingers thus leaving acids and oils on the coins. Every time you open one the coins are exposed to your breath and dirt in the air. Sometimes coins even fall out. And in some instances the glue on the rear of the slots effects the coins.
|
|
Moderator
 United States
188561 Posts |
Folders can be fund and are great for beginners, but albums are always going to be better, even for common circulated coins.
However, when discussing circulated coins, albums being better does not mean folders are all that bad. I think proper storage for albums and folders has the greater affect. You want stable temperature and low humidity.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
 United States
1189 Posts |
Now you guys have got me thinking. Right now my collections are in 2x2's in pages in a 3 ring binder. Unfortunately, every time I upgrade I have to pry the staples out and it becomes a hassle. For missing coins, I either have to leave a blank space in the page to fill later (which leaves a lot of spaces and wasted pages), or I don't account for it and have to re-organize everything when I get a new coin for the set that I was missing. I originally was thinking maybe I would leave my silver sets in the 2x2's and put the clad coins in folders. Unfortunately with the ways the folders are broken up ( Roosevelt dime for example), I'd have to buy 3 folders @ $3 a pop to complete a full set. Alternatively, I can get a Dansco with every year included in one book for a little over $20. Then I could move my silver coins from 2x2's into the album and have everything in one place. I'm tempted to go with Danscos but the price still seems high.. I could spend that money on more coins! To complicate things further, what about the intercept albums? Are those good? Decisions, decisions!
|
|
Moderator
 United States
188561 Posts |
For me, the Dansco albums have paid for themselves over the years of enjoyment. For what it is worth, my oldest Dansco albums are going on 32 years old now.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
1119 Posts |
I seem to be the sole person who prefers Whitman albums over Dansco for the looks. The blue to me looks really nice with silver coins in it.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
 United States
1189 Posts |
Well problem solved. I found a guy on ebay selling lightly used albums. He confirmed they had no writing, tears, etc. picked up 4 Danscos (Kennedy, WL halves, Roosevelt, and IHP) and 3 Whitman albums (Mercury, Jefferson, and Franklin). He cut me a break on price too for buying so many. Now I just need a cent and Washington quarter album and I'll be all set. Highly doubt I'll ever complete the WL, Mercury, or IHP albums but I can certainly fill a decent amount of holes in them!
|
|
Bedrock of the Community
United States
11951 Posts |
Good choice .... I think you will be happy with Dansco albums 
|
|
Moderator
 United States
188561 Posts |
Quote: I seem to be the sole person who prefers Whitman albums over Dansco for the looks. The blue to me looks really nice with silver coins in it. Nope, just carl has been on the Whitman bandwagon for years.  Quote:Well problem solved. I found a guy on ebay selling lightly used albums.... Well done! 
|
|
Valued Member
Slovenia
459 Posts |
I agree with those saying that Whitman's blue and silver coins go together nicely. That is as far as I can go with US coins :D As for my Euro collection, just today I calculated that before my next expanse, I'll probably have to invest about 100 € in capsules, album pages, boxes/trays etc :)
|
|
Rest in Peace
United States
18456 Posts |
I'm a hard core fan of Whitman albums . As far as Wizard goes ; I buy all my supplies from them .
|
| |
Replies: 21 / Views: 7,380 |