Classic US Coin Proof Strikes

As a group the classic coins (mid 1800s to early 1900s) are not all that rare for the most part. Usually the higher face value the higher the price. Small coins are not has popular, and the nickels and cents were often minted in the largest quantties.

Try to buy pieces with original surfaces that have not been dipped, and at least look like they have not been dipped. They cost more, but you won't be looking to replacement them later if you budget grows and you REALLY get into collecting these coins.

This piece as the general look that collectors find desirable.

Examine as many as you can and decide the "look" you like before buying. Buy only a major TPG coin, I suggest. For a combination of value and mid-size importance, I like Barber quarters and V-nickels.

I really like the walking Liberty proofs. While not as old as some of the other coins folks have posted, the WL proof is fairly affordable especially if you buy one from the early 40s.

I have never seen a nice Indian head proof for anywhere near $150 but happy hunting and good luck.

Keep in mind that you can find many very nice examples with good eye appeal that are "only" graded PF61 or PF62 for a lot less than examples that are graded PF65 and above. I wouldn't even look at a modern proof that wasn't graded PF69 or PF70, but it's a whole different ball game with classic proofs.

If you're just starting out and want to find some nice examples that you can afford, consider the following examples from my collection [together with what I originally paid for each coin]:



[$550]



[$725]



[$450]



[$450]



[$300]

Of all of these, the proof Liberty Head Nickel is probably the easiest and cheapest to pick up in nice condition.

Glad you like them! These are really some of my lesser examples, though, since you were talking about entry level coins. Once you get to the point where you're ready to start spending some real money ($1000 and up), you can consider stuff like this:













[If you'd like to see my entire Proof Type Set, click here.]

Barryg that proof Trade dollar is just dragging down your collection. I'll pm you my address so you can send it to me and make your collection look nice again.