Gtg- 1891 CC Morgan Dollar

Definitely a deal, nice acquisition! I'm in the MS64 camp as well with it.

even if the luster is a little more subdued in hand I cant see this getting knocked 2 or 3 full points. worth resub imo. if it comes back even at 64 you would double the value

Was going to say 64

I recently applied to NGC through their ANA membership program, still waiting for my info. This one will be going back, there's too much upside not too. Thanks for all the responses!

TPG got it wrong. I still agree with other opinions at
MS-64.
I would not get it re graded however, because they may still see it the same way as the first time, and re grading fees would be wasted.

A prospective buyer buyer will still assess it for himself anyway, if he is confident in his own grading skills.
With the body of opinion in this thread at higher than MS-62, I think that at least 63 money should be expected.

Nice one!

I think they placed too much emphasis on the cheek dings and the reverse rim ding at 1:00. My first impression was a bourse floor MS-63. I just can't see this one as a 62.

Several ways to go here. You could send it to the bean factory. A bean would certainly make it a bourse floor 63, and a gold bean might even give you a bourse floor argument for 63+/64. You could submit it to PCGS for crossover, with a minimum acceptable grade. I don't think 63 would be a reach, but 64 might be a bridge too far for them. You could submit to NGC for regrade, as long as it is in the original holder. They will reholder it regardless of the new grade, and it can't be lower. You could crack and submit to any of the big three, and hope for a higher grade. (I see very little risk of lower here.)

The only downside would seem to be the submission fee. A VAM-3 bump from 62 to 63 is at least a $250-ish to $300-ish gain.

It's a very nice coin!