Coin Community Family of Web Sites
Shop for APMEX Bullion on eBay!Vancouvers #1 Coin and Paper Money Dealer Coin, Banknote and Medal Collectors's Online Mall Specializing in Modern Numismatics 300,000 items to help build your collection! Shop CCF Members on eBay! Royal Canadian Mint products, Canadian, Polish, American, and world coins and banknotes.








Username:
Password:
Save Password
Forgot your Password?


This page may contain links that result in small commissions to keep this free site up and running.

Welcome Guest! Registering and/or logging in will remove the anchor (bottom) ads. It's Free!

Statehood Quarter Coin Cover Sets & Other Modern Sources For Choice/Gems

To participate in the forum you must log in or register.
Author Previous TopicReplies: 7 / Views: 1,277Next Topic  
Pillar of the Community
captainkurt's Avatar
United States
1406 Posts
 Posted 01/03/2023  7:11 pm Show Profile   Bookmark this topic Add captainkurt to your friends list Get a Link to this Message Number of Subscribers
I have been going through my mint sets collected over 15 years ago. I knew not to expect much after reading posts from Cladking over the years. Still I am surprised how many coins I would not even grade as choice.

I have been going to my LCS and cherry picking sets when they have them in stock. Not much success though in finding very many upgrades.

My main question is where are other good sources to search for choice/gem finds? The Statehood Quarters is an interesting problem for me due to the satin years which I do not collect. Luckily I had rolls of the Presidential dollars stashed away for some of those years to cover my sets.

Does anyone have experience going through the Quarter Coin Covers issued by the mint? The white envelopes with a P & D example.
1) are they business strikes and not satin from 2005-2008?
2) how was the production done for these? Any special handling?
3) could quality be greater than from the mint sets from 1999-2004?

I have felt for a while now that moderns are a great opportunity to collect that most overlook. I am enjoying the challenge in finding quality coins! I can see prices rising so it won't be long and finding higher grades in the wild will get harder and harder. I have also learned so much about grading from moderns without the pain of shelling out huge amounts of money too!

Any discussion on upgrading modern sets to choice and above welcomed!
Edited by captainkurt
01/03/2023 7:12 pm
Pillar of the Community
United States
3207 Posts
 Posted 01/03/2023  11:05 pm  Show Profile   Bookmark this reply Add nick10 to your friends list Get a Link to this Reply
I'd search original bank wrapped rolls. Some rolls have many higher grade coins, some none, depending on how carefully the coins had been treated prior to being rolled.
Moderator
Learn More...
John1's Avatar
United States
56855 Posts
 Posted 01/04/2023  04:15 am  Show Profile   Bookmark this reply Add John1 to your friends list Get a Link to this Reply
I am sure you already thought of this but how about ebay?With most collectors overlooking them the prices might be reasonable on the bay?
John1
Pillar of the Community
captainkurt's Avatar
United States
1406 Posts
 Posted 01/04/2023  10:02 am  Show Profile   Bookmark this reply Add captainkurt to your friends list Get a Link to this Reply
Thank you for the suggestions. I do search mint rolls. I have saved cent, nickel, and dime rolls since 2005. I search rolls of these denominations regularly when I find them at low premiums or score some at the bank. This works great for those denominations. The tricky part is when you get into quarters and dollars. With so many different designs starting in 1999, roll hunting gets cost prohibitive.

Mint sets from the 70"s and 80's are probably my best source to look. I have to see them in person as a huge percentage are junk. That rules out ebay due to lack of detail in the photos. There are souvenir sets from both mints but those are more costly and I have not seen much improvement in quality, correct me if I am wrong on that and haven't searched enough of them.

I stumbled upon these first day of issue coin covers on ebay and that spured me to ask this question. Seems I could get some, sealed, unsearched for about $1-$2 a quarter ($3 a set p&d). Has anyone had luck searching these? First day of issue sounds promising but is there actual quality associated with that statement. Curious how they were handled/produced. Probably from a giant bin of quarter and dollar coins but if truly first runs off the dies, is there a better chance at higher quality coins?

My main question stands regarding your experiences or knowledge with first day coin covers. Statehood Quarters seem to be getting dumped on the market right now so I feel it's a perfect time to find sources to upgrade my moderns from 1999 through the satin years and into the Presidential dollars. I see some ICG sets of quarters graded MS67's that prices are dropping on. I know these are not ms67 but has anyone seen how much lower the do grade?

The 1970's, 80's, and 90's present there own challenges and although any discussion is appreciated, I can't imagine anything but the crappy left over mints sets to be my best inexpensive choice to search. Does anyone have other interesting sources that may yield higher results than just mint sets or expensive rolls? One would think it would be easy to find good examples of modern coins but it is not at all! It is actually a very challenging endeavor.
Pillar of the Community
cladking's Avatar
United States
2270 Posts
 Posted 01/05/2023  2:14 pm  Show Profile   Bookmark this reply Add cladking to your friends list Get a Link to this Reply
I just haven't pursued many coins since the states quarters began. I often call these "ultra-moderns" and, no doubt, I'd have collected them except I developed a condition in 1998 that severely restricted my physical abilities. I'm "better" now but I'm also quite a bit older and am selling due to age rather than seeking new collections. I still watch these markets and keep an eye on the coins in circulation and in coin shops. I don't believe the way to acquire Gems is much different today than it was in 1998; volume. You have to look at a lot of coins and sets and you have to look in the right place to start with. In the old days I could go to a show and find a few Gems in dealer stock. I usually didn't even bother to look at the mint sets unless he obviously had a quantity of nice new sets and then I'd look through those.

And that is the way to find Gems; look for nice new sets at coin shops. I'd reassemble the sets and make sure each was complete with the proper paperwork and the dealers would let me mix and match what I wanted at only a small premium. We'd both come out ahead though at the time the market value greatly favored him because sets were hard to sell at retail and costly to ship. My Gems weren't worth much of anything but they were my goal.

I believe that the "ultra-moderns" actually present more opportunity for the young collector since there are lower mintages and almost as little competition as I had. There is one concern about ultra-moderns that should be kept in mind. Back in the day coins were made on a vast spectrum of quality with most weakly struck and heavily marked before leaving the mint and a very few well struck and clean. This set up the world of today where very high grade clad can sell for a lot of money. Quality improved dramatically in 1999/ '00 so the range isn't as wide and nice coins can be found in bank rolls. It's possible future collectors will be more concerned with mintage again rather than quality in the future.

Another way to find Gems was to watch your change for Gems. When given one at the store just ask what bank they do business with. That bank will probably still have boxes and boxes of similar coins. Go to the same branch. This is actually easier today because in the old days they didn't like providing coins this way. I was in Sandusky, Ohio in April of 1983 looking for the '82-NMM dime. It was too late though I might have been able to find them in bags but the BU's were long gone.

Keep your eyes open, talk to dealers, and check coins. they are always out there. Even today there are still a significant percentage of the sets you encounter in coin shops have never been checked by anyone for anything. A few things are mostly picked out but not so much Gems. You don't see them mostly because they were scarce in the old days and still scarce, even scarcer.
Time don't fly, it bounds and leaps.
Pillar of the Community
captainkurt's Avatar
United States
1406 Posts
 Posted 01/06/2023  5:24 pm  Show Profile   Bookmark this reply Add captainkurt to your friends list Get a Link to this Reply
Thank you for the reply cladking. I am happy you are getting 'better'! There are not too many 'modern' collectors it seems right now so I value your knowledge and input! We're do you sell your coins? I have many holes from the 70's-90's that are going to be a challenge to fill in choice/gem.

I like your distinction between modern and ultra modern. I definitely see the definitive split in quality. Maybe not necessarily quality but design elements that limit the range of difference between BU and gem. Grading seems to be more about damage and not strike quality with ultra moderns.

With the moderns I think I am late to the party. Mint sets are jumping in price and the quality is poor due to damage. My LCS still just unloads them so I search what I can and get an upgrade here and there for a.few bucks as he sells sets for grey sheet bid. I think next I'll have to go to OBW rolls. I don't see many 'sets' of moderns. At least my LCS doesn't buy or sell them.

Aside from volume, you mentioned searching the right place. Hence my question on anyone with experience regarding first day coin covers. I am trying to find innovative 'right places' to look. I purchased 17 unopened Presidential dollar sets at 2x face value. Can't wait to see how the quality is compared to my mint sets. The quarter sets are attainable for about $1.50 a coin for unopened sets (unsearched). This is much more expensive than rolls. I think I will try one full statehood set and see how it turns out. At a minimum they would be easier to flip back on the marketplace than opened singles from bu rolls.

The mintage point you bring up is interesting and I am noticing this in real time by watching the W mint quarters from 'the great American coin hunt.' What a perfect test study to watch and gauge future demand of ultra modern coinage. I have been watching the prices fluctuate as the graded ones hit the market and conditional rarities become known. This mintage point you bring up is well received. I will definitely set aside my extras with this in mind from now on. As you have been preaching people are not paying attention to the attrition of our moderns. Ultra moderns with their lower mintages will be the next generations issues. Much like the issues I am having now trying to get modern gems at a reasonable price.

On to the change thing and bank rolls. There is no doubt I eye BU coins like a hawk to hunt down rolls at face value! I will say tho that the washing solution the mint is using makes many rolls junk. When you find a good roll though, wether it be an error coin or Gem, there will usually be more than one of the same quality or error in the roll. Jackpot!!!

Thank you for your input! I will keep searching and asking questions. Love this forum as it seems to have experts in every corner of the hobby to learn from. I wish we had more people who would recognize the fun and challenges that can be found in the moderns. They are beautiful, varied, and historically interesting. Building my choice to gem ultra modern sets is inexpensive, challenging, and I am sure that the extras that I am able to save, be a good steward for, will provide a lucrative and valuable source for future collectors when I decide to sell 20/30 years from now.

As the the topic of this thread, I have not herd from anyone with experience regarding the quality of the first day issue covers so I am going to purchase more and give updates here just in case someone 10 years from now searches like I did for the information! The dollars should be here soon. The set of quarters next week.

I will say this, the 2005-2010 first day coin covers are much less available. They have been picked over already due to the Satin Mint Set years. Talk about mintages and opportunities! Just look at how much a roll of 2009 nickels sells for.$165 for a $2 roll!!!! People think there is no money or interesting things happening in ultra moderns?
Pillar of the Community
cladking's Avatar
United States
2270 Posts
 Posted 01/07/2023  11:43 am  Show Profile   Bookmark this reply Add cladking to your friends list Get a Link to this Reply
I'm selling only what I can sell at a profit and very few losses. This means it's mostly bulk stuff that has increased and a few high grades. The high grades are slabbed and auctioned but I do sell a few for very low prices (20 - $30 each) on the net to interested buyers. These are really nice high grades that are "out of the money" and not worth the cost of slabbing at this time. Most of the stuff is going to wholesalers who have been scrambling to get stock in nice attractive moderns. I hate to sell it so cheap but my heirs would do even worse. Once in a while I'll offer something on one of the coin forums and may be offering '82 and '83 mint sets by next autumn. I paid very high prices for most of these and only bought the finest. I'm probably going to sell the bad ones cheap, the nice ones (most of them) very high and cut out the highest grades since I don't have enough envelopes for all of them anyway.

I've still got a long way to go and have emptied only half of my safety deposit boxes. I really hate to be selling but I can console myself that at least I'm selling into a strong market. Otherwise I'd be hauling a lot more to the bank.


Quote:
I definitely see the definitive split in quality. Maybe not necessarily quality but design elements that limit the range of difference between BU and gem.


My thinking here is that it's only natural for collectors to gravitate to the highest grades in the older moderns because nice specimens are so uncommon. Some of the ultramoderns might not develop as much of a following in high grades since if you can't afford an MS-67 an MS-66 might be very inexpensive. The long run always remains to be seen.


Quote:
With the moderns I think I am late to the party. Mint sets are jumping in price and the quality is poor due to damage. My LCS still just unloads them so I search what I can and get an upgrade here and there for a.few bucks as he sells sets for grey sheet bid. I think next I'll have to go to OBW rolls. I don't see many 'sets' of moderns. At least my LCS doesn't buy or sell them.


Demand for moderns is soaring so in a sense you really are late to the party but there are lots of coins out there that have still never been looked at. An individual could get first crack at a lot of them with obnly a few good contacts. Also don't forget prices on many scarce items have hardly budged because demand ois still "unsophisticated"; collectors are still working without good price guides so scarce items are available far too cheaply.

"Modern" applies across the board to almost all world and US coins plus tokens and medals. Most of this stuff is terra incognito where it's first come first served. And "modern" means something very different in different collectibles with some from as far back as 1919 having almost no demand or supply.

Just poking around a shop recently I found an MS-67 heavily frosted '66 quarter in a set. I bought the small stack found three keepers and wholesaled the rest at a small profit. To me the three keepers make it a huge profit.


Quote:
Aside from volume, you mentioned searching the right place.


This is important though perhaps not so important as it once was. With limited time and resources you just can't check everything.

I just don't know about first day covers. I once saw a spectacular Gem in one struck on burnished planchets but haven't seen enough of these to know. Ultra-modern mint sets are often spectacular. Where I'd have to look through dozens of sets to find something so spectacular now days there can be two or three in a set.

The mint does toy with collectors and might hide Gems almost anywhere. While I've never seen any of the late date souvenir sets I'm told that the coins in these are sometimes top notch. Back in the SMS days one set would look like it was all run over by a forklift and the next set would have all spectacular coins. The mint never even admitted they put Gems in mint sets until 1997!!! Their literature always said mint set coins were regular production uncirculated coins. But in point of fact virtually every Gem made in many years went into a mint set. They simply made mint set coins to a far higher standard. If you think about it this is why there are no BU rolls; if the mint set coins are awful imagine what the coins in BU rolls looked like. People just didn't save them.


Quote:
I will say tho that the washing solution the mint is using makes many rolls junk.


I've had to cash in hundreds of BU rolls at the bank. Over the years I saved a few nice rolls when I had the opportunity. Most of these were quite scarce and will have a premium some day but I couldn't wait. I checked them all for Gems and varieties but many of the coins were dark and splotchy so they went to the bank.


Quote:
Love this forum as it seems to have experts in every corner of the hobby to learn from. I wish we had more people who would recognize the fun and challenges that can be found in the moderns.


This is one of the best coin forums on the net. I have a low "threshold" for posting here.

You think moderns are lonely now you shouldda been around 50 years ago. People would get irate if I told them I collected clad coins.

Good luck with having fun and helping future collectors and hopefully at a tidy profit. I'm confident you'll do well in any of your endeavors.
Time don't fly, it bounds and leaps.
Pillar of the Community
captainkurt's Avatar
United States
1406 Posts
 Posted 01/08/2023  2:21 pm  Show Profile   Bookmark this reply Add captainkurt to your friends list Get a Link to this Reply
Thanks again for your insight cladking. I will be sending you a PM today.


Quote:
Some of the ultramoderns might not develop as much of a following in high grades since if you can't afford an MS-67 an MS-66 might be very inexpensive.


I find your point regarding ultra moderns interesting. As long as the coins are not banged up to the naked eye than a simple collection price seems to fit the bill for most collectors right now. Afterall, there are sooo many different collections now with 20+ coin mint sets. So far in my post satin year sets it is not uncommon to find a couple MS66 coins in each set. Then half seem to be Choice and half BU.


By the way, here is my trade list of extras here on CCF
http://goccf.com/t/414752


With such nice coins to be found in the sets there may not be the attrition of quality coins for the next generation like there are for the moderns today that got damaged by mint packaging. I think you are right to watch for mintage figures to find the conditional rarity key coins. However, I think more people are saving rolls now compared to the modern coinage days as the holding costs are lower with the buying power of the dollar so much lower than it was in the 70's & 80's

The Presidential dollar First Day Issue Coin Covers are a bust! I opened half of the 17 I got for 2x face value. The coins are not even worthy of a BU designation. They are spenders. I found a couple choice coins but even these are not marketable or upgrades for the ones I have found in rolls.

I will be getting the State Quarter ones this week. I will see how those go and post here. Average price for a BU State Quarter set is about $75. Picked up the First Day covers for $100. If anything at least with both the presidential covers and the quarter covers I will know they are business strikes and not satins.



  Previous TopicReplies: 7 / Views: 1,277Next Topic  

To participate in the forum you must log in or register.



    




Disclaimer: While a tremendous amount of effort goes into ensuring the accuracy of the information contained in this site, Coin Community assumes no liability for errors. Copyright 2005 - 2026 Coin Community Family- all rights reserved worldwide. Use of any images or content on this website without prior written permission of Coin Community or the original lender is strictly prohibited.
Contact Us  |  Advertise Here  |  Privacy Policy / Terms of Use

Coin Community Forum © 2005 - 2026 Coin Community Forums
It took 0.36 seconds to rattle this change. Forums