Coin Community Forum

Join Thousands of Coin, Bullion, & Money Collectors

Coin, Banknote and Medal Collectors's Online Mall

Vancouvers #1 Coin and Paper Money Dealer

Royal Canadian Mint products, Canadian, Polish, American, and world coins and banknotes.

300,000 items to help build your collection!

Royal Estate Auctions - $1 Coin Auctions

Search Coin Community

CCF Social Media

Coin Community Time

Be a Site Supporter

General

Facebook Pinterest Youtube Channel Stamp Forum Coin Forum Mints Spot Prices Numismatic Search Engine Numismatic Glossary Numismatic Articles Numismatic Event Calendar Numismatic People Appraising A Coin Collection Advertise Here Contact Us

CCF Recommended

eBay Amazon MA-Shops

US Coins & Currency

US Coin Facts US Colonial Coins US Mint Sets US Proof Sets US Pattern Coins US Coin Grading US Coin History US Classic Commemorative Facts US Paper Money Facts

Australian Coins

Perth Mint NCLT Mintages Perth Mint Coin Programs Perth Mint Latest Releases

Canadian Coins

Canadian Coin Facts Canadian Coin Grading Canadian Commemoratives

eBay Coin Shopping

Search CCF Members

eBay Tools eBay Coin Search Engine eBay Coin Categories All eBay Categories eBay / CCF Member List eBay / CCF Member Sales Popular Items Error Coins US Error Coins US Cheap Coins US Hot Coins US Most Watched Coins Aussie Cheap Coins Aussie Hot Coins Aussie Most Watched Coins Canadian Cheap Coins Canadian Hot Coins Canadian Most Watched Coins Ancient Cheap Coins Ancient Hot Coins Ancient Most Watched Coins World Cheap Coins World Hot Coins World Most Watched Coins eBay Coins By Type eBay Coins By Year

Active Users

There are currently 99,824 users on this website.

Stuff for Members

Recent Forum Topics

Last 100 Active Topics Last 100 New Topics

New CCF Member Sales

For Sale: Canadian NCLT And NGC Shipwreck El Cazador 8-Reale For Sale: 1909 -P Lincoln Wheat Cent 1835 25c Removed From PCGS AU-58 Holder For Sale: 1943 -S Steel Lincoln Wheat Cent For Sale - Silver Dimes Below Melt For Sale Silver Eagles For Sale: My Numismatic Book Collection Coin Community Selling Rules - Updated June 5, 2025 Coin Community Selling Questions

Home Member CCF Sales Member eBay Sales New Posts Unanswered Search Tutorials FAQ Rules

This page may contain links that result in small commissions to keep this free site up and running.

Welcome Guest! Registering and/or logging in will remove the anchor (bottom) ads. It's Free!

All Forums Search Form Search Results for: All non-archived Topics that contain posts by rlu7732. There are 134 results found.

	Topic	Author	Replies	Read	Last Post
US Coins and Currency Discussion Forums / US Modern Coins
	Project $100k - Circulating U. S. Half Dollar Coins 1 2 3 4 5 =>134 135 136 137 138 Last	CoinHuntingDrew 12/10/2015	2064	180890	Yesterday 3:25 pm by: hokiefan_82
	Project $100k - Circulating US Dollar Coins 1 2 3 4 5 =>181 182 183 184 185 Last	Bryan78 12/10/2015	2764	217098	Yesterday 07:56 am by: Dearborn
	Easiest Coin Series To Collect? 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Last	Humanist1287 11/21/2024	99	12200	08/25/2025 09:58 am by: Dearborn
	Bank Box Of 2023-P Nickels 1 2 Last	snailking1 05/13/2025	16	1712	05/15/2025 11:58 am by: jbuck
	Are These Jefferson Nickels Worth Searching Through? 1 2 Last	lvtwentytwo 05/12/2025	17	2337	05/14/2025 9:25 pm by: lvtwentytwo
	House Introduces Common Cents Act To Cut The Penny 1 2 3 Last	rlu7732 05/01/2025	43	4346	05/12/2025 11:06 am by: jbuck
	Modern Releases From The US Mint 1 2 3 Last	seamonkey5150 04/22/2025	31	3044	04/28/2025 1:14 pm by: jbuck
	1972-D Washington Quarter - Proof Like 1 2 Last	rlu7732 04/06/2025	16	2556	04/21/2025 8:02 pm by: rlu7732
	US Treasury Ordered To Stop Producing New Cents 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 Last	PastExpiry 02/09/2025	194	18799	04/21/2025 11:20 am by: jbuck
	Are You Buying Boxes Of Pennies, Cents Now That They Stopped Making Them? 1 2 3 4 5 Last	edteach 02/10/2025	65	8540	04/14/2025 11:52 am by: jbuck
	Mint Sets 1968 - Date Good For Quality Coins 1 2 Last	seamonkey5150 03/31/2025	17	2170	04/02/2025 3:26 pm by: jbuck
	1976-D Kennedy Half Dollar (Proof-Like)	rlu7732 03/28/2025	10	1028	03/29/2025 1:47 pm by: Dearborn
	Getting Rolls From Banks 1 2 Last	Gamall Maor 02/10/2025	18	2624	02/13/2025 9:25 pm by: Gamall Maor
	1965 SMS Dime - Cam/D-Cam Designation	rlu7732 01/18/2025	1	476	01/19/2025 01:49 am by: Marv65
	Original Unopened Mint Sealed Box - 1981	rlu7732 01/16/2025	14	1444	01/18/2025 09:20 am by: Morgans Dad
	My Friend's LMC Hoard To Be Searched. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Last	Brandmeister 12/22/2024	84	6459	01/16/2025 4:50 pm by: rlu7732
US Coins and Currency Discussion Forums / US Modern Variety and Error Coins
	1964 Proof Washington Quarter - DDR/Tdr	rlu7732 11/19/2025	7	535	11/20/2025 09:31 am by: jbuck
	1964 Proof Half Dollar, T/Qdo?	SilverStackerKid 11/14/2025	10	762	11/16/2025 2:44 pm by: jbuck
	1977 Roosevelt Dime - Machine Damage	rlu7732 11/14/2025	5	466	11/16/2025 2:38 pm by: jbuck
	1954-D Washington Quarter - Extra Leaf	rlu7732 11/11/2025	8	634	11/11/2025 8:52 pm by: Earle42
	1943 Lincoln Cent - Struck Through(?)	rlu7732 10/29/2025	15	646	10/31/2025 3:10 pm by: -makecents-
	1956 Franklin Half Dollar - Reverse Doubled	rlu7732 09/27/2025	10	971	10/08/2025 04:06 am by: 144233
	1964 Kennedy Proof Half Dollar - Type 1 Reverse	rlu7732 10/01/2025	5	578	10/02/2025 10:58 am by: jbuck
	2024-D Roosevelt Dime - Unsure Reverse Leaf	rlu7732 08/07/2025	4	429	08/08/2025 09:47 am by: jbuck
	2024-D Mary Edwards Walker Quarter - Doubled Die Reverse	rlu7732 08/07/2025	4	529	08/08/2025 09:45 am by: jbuck
	2024-D Kennedy Half Dollar - Raised Star On Obverse 1 2 3 Last	rlu7732 03/04/2025	41	5897	07/29/2025 11:05 am by: mikediamond
	1961 Proof Jefferson Nickel - Overweight	rlu7732 07/14/2025	8	550	07/14/2025 2:35 pm by: jbuck
	1960 Proof Franklin Half Dollar - FS-101?	rlu7732 06/18/2025	8	802	06/20/2025 4:53 pm by: rlu7732
	1965 Washington Quarter Out Of SMS? 1 2 Last	armandoluna 05/13/2025	29	2554	05/19/2025 11:26 am by: armandoluna
	(1990) Weird Lincoln Cent.what Could Explain This?	tjmakov 05/13/2025	14	1208	05/15/2025 2:01 pm by: Sharks
	1964-D Roosevelt Dime - Obverse Dots	rlu7732 05/13/2025	5	540	05/14/2025 3:08 pm by: rlu7732
	1990-S Proof Quarter - Unknown Obverse	rlu7732 05/12/2025	6	696	05/13/2025 09:40 am by: jbuck
	2024 Half Dollar Error Or Damage	Smuncher 05/08/2025	15	2651	05/12/2025 06:52 am by: Petespockets55
	1969-S Proof Washington Quarter - RPM?	rlu7732 05/08/2025	15	1292	05/10/2025 7:16 pm by: -makecents-
	1983 Lincoln Memorial Penny - Design Elements	rlu7732 04/28/2025	6	721	04/29/2025 09:30 am by: jbuck
	1971-D Washington Quarter - Second Initials Or "E"?	rlu7732 04/26/2025	5	738	04/28/2025 8:07 pm by: rlu7732
	In My Place, What Would You Do? 1 2 Last	jdsstrat 04/25/2025	22	2182	04/28/2025 12:06 pm by: jbuck
	2020-S $1 American Innovation SC - Strike Question	rlu7732 04/23/2025	10	827	04/23/2025 5:41 pm by: Cujohn
	2019 W American Memorial Possible Strikethrough Error!	arby96 04/23/2025	8	762	04/23/2025 5:28 pm by: Cujohn
	2020-S $1 American Innovation CT - DDR Or Frosting Offset	rlu7732 04/23/2025	4	728	04/23/2025 5:11 pm by: jbuck
	1977-D Nickel - Reverse Window	rlu7732 04/07/2025	11	895	04/07/2025 9:07 pm by: Dearborn
	1994-P Roosevelt Dime - Reverse (Unknown)	rlu7732 04/01/2025	5	896	04/02/2025 3:20 pm by: Marv65
	1960 Jefferson Nickel - Doubled Die Reverse	rlu7732 03/30/2025	8	921	03/31/2025 1:48 pm by: Earle42
	1964-D Washington Quarter - Mintmark	rlu7732 03/27/2025	4	673	03/28/2025 10:52 am by: Dearborn
	1976 Bicentennial Quarter Above My Coinage Knowledge	Frankrizzo 03/24/2025	3	774	03/24/2025 10:34 pm by: Dearborn
	1971-S Silver Proof Ike Dollar Missing Cameo Frosting On Reverse	amnight 03/23/2025	6	868	03/24/2025 11:47 am by: jbuck
	2025-S Native American $1 Proof - Doubled Edge Lettering	rlu7732 03/22/2025	12	1207	03/24/2025 01:08 am by: rlu7732
	Misapplied Frosting (Slop) - Any Extra Value? (2025-S Proof Dime) 1 2 Last	rlu7732 03/22/2025	18	1753	03/23/2025 7:59 pm by: rlu7732
	2020 Lincoln Shield Penny With DDR Traits	eagle2a1 03/09/2025	8	1129	03/18/2025 3:54 pm by: coin rejector
	2023 Half Dollar Doubled Die?	domd1684 03/12/2025	10	1028	03/16/2025 12:40 pm by: coin rejector
	Split Serifs? Is This A Lincoln 1984 DDR?	ooburgeoo 03/13/2025	11	1169	03/14/2025 1:33 pm by: coin rejector
	Missing Clad , Roosevelt Dime. Take 2 :)	CoinVixen 03/11/2025	12	1083	03/14/2025 01:14 am by: Errers and Varietys
	2024-D Missouri Dollar Coin - Raised Design Elements	rlu7732 03/12/2025	7	677	03/14/2025 01:07 am by: Errers and Varietys
	2024-D George Washington Carver Dollar - Doubled Or?	rlu7732 03/08/2025	10	867	03/14/2025 12:57 am by: Errers and Varietys
	1965 Dime On Wrong Silver Planchet?	Vervar 03/08/2025	15	1592	03/14/2025 12:54 am by: Errers and Varietys
	2006 Lincoln DDO Fs001 Or 002?	wrongalot 03/09/2025	6	632	03/14/2025 12:19 am by: Errers and Varietys
	1972-D Washington Quarter - Die Or Planchet Issue	rlu7732 03/08/2025	5	823	03/14/2025 12:15 am by: Errers and Varietys
	Question About Intentional Errors. 1 2 Last	CerealxKiller 03/11/2025	19	2021	03/13/2025 9:22 pm by: Sap
	Benjamin Franklin 1961 D RPM 001 ?	Lenzos 57 02/23/2025	8	906	03/13/2025 11:59 am by: jbuck
	1971-D Kennedy Half - DDO FS-101 Possibly?	armandoluna 03/07/2025	7	1035	03/11/2025 12:13 pm by: atrox001
	"America The Beautiful" Quarter 2018 D Error	Anzelmas 03/08/2025	5	744	03/08/2025 1:09 pm by: Dearborn
	2018-D Lincoln Shield Penny (Unknown Initials Error)	rlu7732 02/23/2025	8	833	02/27/2025 09:07 am by: ijn1944
	1977-D Kennedy Half Dollar Reverse Lettering	rlu7732 02/24/2025	11	758	02/26/2025 6:44 pm by: rlu7732
	Kennedy Half Dollar 1996 P. Ghost 2?	Lenzos 57 02/26/2025	5	706	02/26/2025 3:39 pm by: Dearborn
	1968 Lincoln Memorial Penny - Extra Column On Reverse?	rlu7732 02/26/2025	6	701	02/26/2025 12:07 pm by: Errers and Varietys
	Sacagawea 2000-P Dollar Re Engraved Eagle?	amnight 02/25/2025	12	822	02/25/2025 6:29 pm by: Brandmeister
	1966 SMS Jefferson Nickel - Letter Formations	rlu7732 02/25/2025	9	682	02/25/2025 4:46 pm by: Dearborn
	1999 Lincoln Memorial Penny Doubled Ear Lobe? 1 2 Last	Littlemg2 02/23/2025	16	1722	02/25/2025 10:44 am by: ErrorHunter1
	2023-P Jefferson Nickel DDR	RobO411 02/23/2025	7	874	02/24/2025 12:52 pm by: RobO411
	Washington Quarter 1961 DDO Or MD	Lenzos 57 02/23/2025	4	584	02/23/2025 8:14 pm by: Chase007
	1989-D Kennedy Half Dollar Doubling	rlu7732 02/22/2025	10	799	02/23/2025 5:48 pm by: Cujohn
	Please Help Looking For Help With Half Dollar Coin Roll Hunting	Coins4ourkids 02/22/2025	4	1500	02/22/2025 9:16 pm by: Dearborn
	1969-D Lincoln Memorial Penny - Odd Letters And Design Underneath	rlu7732 02/21/2025	7	741	02/21/2025 6:19 pm by: Cujohn
	1964-D Jefferson Nickel RPM (Fs-501)	rlu7732 02/18/2025	6	1068	02/20/2025 12:50 pm by: Brandmeister
	1972 D Quarter (Cud Or Part Of Rim?)	rlu7732 02/07/2025	5	447	02/09/2025 1:57 pm by: jbuck
	2023-D Bessie Coleman Quarter Liberty Doubling	rlu7732 02/01/2025	4	512	02/02/2025 05:43 am by: Dearborn
	1984 D Lincoln Memorial Penny	rlu7732 01/18/2025	10	702	01/21/2025 10:10 pm by: Seeker_101
	1972 P LMC DDO-002 FS-102 MS-65 RD 1 2 Last	Jim0815 01/18/2025	20	1540	01/20/2025 4:18 pm by: jbuck
	1967 Jefferson Nickel Face Thickness	rlu7732 01/18/2025	7	640	01/20/2025 11:09 am by: jbuck
	1979 Susan B Anthony Dollar Doubling(?)	rlu7732 01/18/2025	7	562	01/20/2025 11:07 am by: jbuck
	1984 D Roosevelt Dime - Machine Doubling Or DDO?	rlu7732 01/18/2025	7	586	01/18/2025 6:54 pm by: oddguy
	1960 D Lincoln Cent Questions	Gigi2 01/18/2025	4	510	01/18/2025 6:10 pm by: Dearborn
	2022 D Lincoln Shield Penny - Post Mint Damage(?)	rlu7732 12/27/2024	11	729	12/28/2024 10:10 pm by: jbuck
	1964-D Lincoln Memorial Penny Unsure What To Call It	rlu7732 12/24/2024	9	571	12/25/2024 12:43 pm by: Dearborn
	1972 S Lincoln Memorial Penny RPM(?)	rlu7732 12/22/2024	6	512	12/23/2024 5:41 pm by: Dearborn
	1974-D Lincoln Memorial Reverse Doubling	rlu7732 12/06/2024	7	487	12/09/2024 12:17 pm by: jbuck
	2019 P Lincoln Memorial Penny Font	rlu7732 12/04/2024	6	801	12/05/2024 4:29 pm by: Cujohn
	2024-D Lincoln Shield Penny Error	rlu7732 11/06/2024	6	3060	11/07/2024 04:25 am by: John1
	1995 P Roosevelt Dime - Die Deterioration	rlu7732 10/29/2024	6	472	10/31/2024 4:20 pm by: Dearborn
	2024-D Lincoln Penny Doubled Ear	rlu7732 10/29/2024	7	2940	10/29/2024 07:51 am by: Dearborn
	1994 No Mint Mark Die Crack (Maybe?)	rlu7732 10/24/2024	11	891	10/24/2024 7:40 pm by: Marv65
US Coins and Currency Discussion Forums / US Modern Coin Grading
	1954 Washington Quarter 1 2 Last	rlu7732 09/27/2025	18	1745	01/20/2026 08:37 am by: Dearborn
	1977-D Eisenhower Ike Dollar	rlu7732 10/09/2025	8	657	10/10/2025 7:26 pm by: mcshilling
	1954-S Franklin Half Dollar	rlu7732 09/27/2025	11	997	10/02/2025 11:21 am by: jbuck
	1972 DDO-001 Cent Grade ?	jfeed 05/10/2025	8	1208	05/14/2025 8:06 pm by: rlu7732
	1966 Lincoln Memorial Cent, Struck On 10c Clad Planchet - You Vs. PCGS	joeturbo26 04/22/2025	7	1035	04/24/2025 11:59 am by: rlu7732
	1960 Franklin Half Dollar - Help With Cam/DCAM Designation	rlu7732 03/28/2025	7	975	03/30/2025 8:01 pm by: rlu7732
	1957 Franklin Half Dollar	rlu7732 03/28/2025	5	701	03/28/2025 10:49 pm by: Freespeech57
	1964 Proof Lincoln Memorial Penny (What Grade?)	rlu7732 03/26/2025	9	920	03/27/2025 9:23 pm by: rlu7732
	United States Proof Sets	j5x429 03/22/2025	10	1256	03/23/2025 8:11 pm by: rlu7732
	1966 Dimes, What Is Cosidered FB	armandoluna 03/06/2025	3	726	03/07/2025 10:47 pm by: rlu7732
	1986-P Lincoln Cent - Grade It!	BadThad 02/25/2025	13	1035	03/03/2025 10:45 pm by: BadThad
	1917 In Good, Fair Or Poor Condition?	LadyT351 02/26/2025	11	1020	02/28/2025 09:39 am by: jbuck
	I Have A Coin That Is Toned! It's A 1958-D Washington	Willburton 02/26/2025	14	852	02/28/2025 07:15 am by: ijn1944
	1964 Proof Jefferson Nickel - What Would You Give It?	rlu7732 02/26/2025	5	586	02/27/2025 11:18 am by: jbuck
	2006-D Lincoln Memorial Penny	rlu7732 02/18/2025	13	1088	02/25/2025 11:29 pm by: rlu7732
	1995-D Lincoln Memorial Penny (What Did PCGS Grade It)	rlu7732 02/25/2025	9	802	02/25/2025 10:31 pm by: BadThad
	1994 Lincoln Memorial Penny (Sending To PCGS)	rlu7732 02/19/2025	11	1176	02/25/2025 05:26 am by: TeeEss86
	1967 Jefferson Nickel You Vs. NGC 1 2 Last	captainkurt 02/18/2025	16	1476	02/24/2025 06:54 am by: panzaldi
	1994-D Washington Quarter	rlu7732 02/15/2025	8	1010	02/24/2025 06:43 am by: panzaldi
	1989-D Lincoln Memorial Penny, What Would PCGS Grade This? 1 2 Last	rlu7732 02/18/2025	16	1321	02/19/2025 4:48 pm by: ErrorHunter1
	1957 Washington Proof Quarter (Which Designation?)	rlu7732 01/23/2025	7	559	01/24/2025 2:37 pm by: rlu7732
	1972 D Kennedy Half Dollar	rlu7732 01/16/2025	5	612	01/16/2025 5:08 pm by: IndianGoldEagle
US Coins and Currency Discussion Forums / US Classic and Colonial Coins
	1880 Morgan Dollar - Eds	rlu7732 12/21/2025	8	809	12/24/2025 10:26 am by: NumismaticsFTW
	1921 Zerbe Special Strike (?)	rlu7732 12/15/2025	3	579	12/16/2025 10:42 pm by: NumismaticsFTW
	1922 Peace Dollar Toning 1 2 Last	mikev50 12/03/2025	17	1535	12/12/2025 12:01 pm by: DOCC
	1886 Morgan Dollar - Proof Like (?)	rlu7732 09/28/2025	11	1358	09/30/2025 5:14 pm by: jbuck
	What Source Do Some Of You Use To Value Your Coins? 1 2 Last	j5x429 03/07/2025	19	2652	03/24/2025 03:07 am by: TinyRetreat
	1896 Indian Cent Unknown X	rlu7732 01/30/2025	12	958	02/04/2025 09:16 am by: jbuck
US Coins and Currency Discussion Forums / US Classic and Colonial Variety and Error Coins
	1878-S Morgan Dollar - Mint Mark Question	rlu7732 12/11/2025	7	501	12/12/2025 09:27 am by: Dearborn
	1887 Morgan Dollar - Markings On Obverse	rlu7732 06/24/2025	9	932	06/25/2025 10:36 am by: johnnysprawl
US Coins and Currency Discussion Forums / US Peace and Morgan Dollar VAM
	1880 Morgan Dollar - VAM 32A Or 24A?	rlu7732 12/11/2025	12	610	12/12/2025 07:57 am by: -makecents-
US Coins and Currency Discussion Forums / US Classic and Colonial Coin Grading
	1900 Morgan Dollar - GTG	rlu7732 12/19/2025	12	869	12/25/2025 10:29 am by: panzaldi
	1881-S Morgan Dollar - GTG	rlu7732 12/16/2025	15	788	12/20/2025 10:22 am by: panzaldi
	1906 Barber Quarter - Grade Opinion	rlu7732 12/07/2025	7	543	12/08/2025 7:17 pm by: rlu7732
	1921 Morgan Dollar - GTG	rlu7732 11/14/2025	13	807	11/26/2025 11:58 pm by: Odee13
	1908 Indian Cent - Grade Opinion 1 2 Last	rlu7732 11/15/2025	24	1407	11/17/2025 09:50 am by: panzaldi
	1880-S Morgan Dollar	rlu7732 11/15/2025	6	533	11/17/2025 08:59 am by: panzaldi
	1922 Peace Dollar Grade Opinions	rlu7732 09/29/2025	8	1181	10/04/2025 1:22 pm by: Prethen
	1945 Walking Liberty Half Dollar	rlu7732 09/27/2025	10	912	09/29/2025 5:53 pm by: IndianGoldEagle
	1945-D Walking Liberty Half Dollar	rlu7732 06/29/2025	9	1513	08/26/2025 10:55 pm by: numismatic student
General Numismatic Discussion Forums / "Post Your..." Gallery Topics
	Eye Candy Corner: Post Your Toned Coins! 1 2 3 4 5 =>366 367 368 369 370 Last	wheatguy 09/19/2009	5541	432033	06/30/2026 7:35 pm by: Dearborn
General Numismatic Discussion Forums / Coin Roll Hunting
	Uncirculated Rolls Of Pre-1982 Cents	rlu7732 02/20/2025	6	774	02/21/2025 07:18 am by: nickelsearcher
General Numismatic Discussion Forums / Coin Photography, Image Editing, and Related Software
	Best Microscope Coin Collecting 1 2 Last	Double J 02/11/2024	18	9583	10/30/2025 08:54 am by: jbuck

New posts since last logon.
Old Posts. ( 30 replies or more.)
Locked topic.

The First Dollar, your premier source for bullion and rare coins. See our bullion list on the site and the coin inventory on ebay.

Silver Gold Bull US is the United States leading bullion dealer. We deliver gold coins, gold bars, silver coins, silver bars and precious metals to your door. Order today!

View Last 100 New Topics

View Last 100 Active Topics

Disclaimer: While a tremendous amount of effort goes into ensuring the accuracy of the information contained in this site, Coin Community assumes no liability for errors. Copyright 2005 - 2026 Coin Community Family- all rights reserved worldwide. Use of any images or content on this website without prior written permission of Coin Community or the original lender is strictly prohibited.
Contact Us | Advertise Here | Privacy Policy / Terms of Use

Coin Community Forum

It took 0.44 seconds to rattle this change.