Statehood Quarter Question

Well, as far as metal content goes, an S-mint State Quarter has the exact same composition as a P or D-mint coin, so in that regard they aren't worth more. (Silver proofs, of course, are a different story entirely.)

So, any premium over face value would be entirely due to their status as "proof" coins which are much more attractive (in the opinion of most) than regular business strikes. That having been said, not all proof coins are created equal - some proof coins have been known to pick up slight blemishes during the manufacturing/packaging process at the Mint, and then they might be subject to possible additional damage after leaving the mint, depending on how they are handled. A proof with a fingerprint, scratches, or other damage from careless handling is going to probably be worth very little over face value.

$250 for 56 coins works out to $4.46 per coin. I recently completed a set of Cu-Ni State Quarter proofs - I paid more than that for some, less than that for others. It might be helpful to see some pictures of this set to get an idea of their condition and packaging - it might be helpful in getting a good answer. But, I don't think $250 for 56 proof coins is completely out of line at this point. If you are looking to get the whole set in one shot, then paying a little bit more for the extra convenience as opposed to getting each coin individually might be worth it to you.

Build a set of the silver proofs for as close to melt price as possible. Cost is a bit more but you WILL get your moneys worth so to speak. (Plus I actually like the look better then regular proofs) Right now a set of 56 silver proof quarters (if bought for melt price) would be about $300.00. I think this would be your best option for both posterity, looks, and value going forward.

No, $250 for the CuNi proofs is entirely way too high. A couple of places were selling the quarters in OGP w/o boxes or COAs for $79.95, one retailer that offered this deal during the year was South Park Coins in Texas. Not sure if they still are offering it. Believe they now have a web site.

If you are looking for just the uncirculated coins, Valley Coin (www.valleycoin.com) has the full 112-coin set for $67.95, the 100-coin set for $54.95 and a single mint 50coin set for $35.95. They also have the CuNi proofs for $125.00. Shipping is always a mere $5.49, and they are FAST and really friendly folks over there in Minn.

Captain Kurt is right about the silver proofs, but you probably could not get the set for $300.00. I have built three sets so far this year and the average range of the set price has been between $435.00 and $470.00. They look great too when white and untoned.

Otherwise, just build a set from circulation for $12.50

I have built and bought complete sets of the proofs and silver proofs. In my opinion, even with the airtites and the display box, you could build that set yourself at a fraction of that cost.

Buy the coins, not the holder.